Pirates Prospects Daily: Finding Value In JT Brubaker For 2023, And Beyond

It’s easy to overlook the work that JT Brubaker has done since making his major league debut back in 2020. If anything, he’s been consistent, as he is one of 76 pitchers since 2020 to throw at least 300 innings, leading the Pirates in that span as well.

While he hasn’t posted the most eye popping of numbers, he’s posted some fairly strong metrics as well – 3.96 xFIP, 23.3 K%, and 11.8 SwStr%. 

Even more impressive, is that he’s in camp and gearing up for what he’s hoping will be his best season yet, as he tries to incorporate his changeup more than previous seasons, which would give a different look to hitters.

The Pirates are set to have numerous of their pitching prospects set to begin the season in Indianapolis this year. Even though they look like the obvious intention is to be more competitive this year, it is hard to see a scenario where they are going to be held back once they are deemed ‘ready’.

So, where would that leave Brubaker? As the Pirates start to bring up some of the prospects, it would be nice to have some reliable arms still around that you know what you are going to get. 

Then again, you are going to have to make room for the prospects, which could impact Brubaker. Vince Velasquez and Rich Hill were brought in on one year deals, so they could be the easy answer to make space.

The Pirates could take advantage of Brubaker about to enter arbitration, along with the fact he’s proven to be a reliable back-end of the rotation starter, and trade him while his value is high, especially if he plays well this season.

Or they can hang on to him, and have him round out a rotation that will have several young pitchers in it as they find their footing at the Major League level.

Regardless, Brubaker can end up being a very valuable piece for the organization, whether it be with the Pirates, or as a trade piece.

Pirates Prospects Daily

By Tim Williams

**Pirates DVR: Braeden Ogle Returns, Caleb Smith, Blake Cederlind Live BP

**Termarr Johnson Returns to Minor League Camp The first cut of the spring was brought on by a minor injury

**Pirates Discussion: Build Up For The Season

**Pirates Prospects Daily: Mitch Keller Gets Nod First Spring Game… Opening Day? In case you missed it from yesterday, Mitch Keller will be starting the spring opener…today.

Song of the Day

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xuIAcZ_BS64

TODAY’S LINEUP

Lineups for Spring Training will be posted at the bottom of this article each day. Today’s scheduled pitchers are listed at the bottom. Game is at 1:05 PM

Pitchers following Keller: Roansy Contreras, David Bednar, Jarlin Garcia, Chase De Jong, Duane Underwood Jr., Daniel Zamora and Rob Zastryzny.

Anthony began writing over 10 years ago, starting a personal blog to cover the 2011 MLB draft, where the Pirates selected first overall. After bouncing around many websites covering hockey, he refocused his attention to baseball, his first love when it comes to sports. He eventually found himself here at Pirates Prospects in late 2021, where he covers the team’s four full season minor league affiliates.

Support Pirates Prospects

Related articles

join the discussion

Subscribe
Notify of
68 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
PiratePrimate

Two and a half hour baseball!! Just like 50 years ago.

PiratePrimate

And watching Blake Sabol hit and catch for the Giants I have to wonder what the hell the Pirates were thinking in not protecting him?

EightMenOut

With Perez signed to a $2.5 million contract it is hard to see how the giants keep him on the 26 man roster. Which still doesn’t mean he will return to Pittsburgh

PiratePrimate

We’ll see. But the Giants organization knows what they’re doing and I wouldn’t be surprised to see Sabol make the roster. He can hit.

Scam likely

Well first game scouting report, need better lhp relief, and not impressed with corner outfielders lefties or righties. Also like to see some younger harder throwing relief pitchers from the system. Struck out 16 times today but walked 8 times. 2:48 minutes time of the game is nice too see.

1979andCounting

Zamora LH – soft tosser, small stature, 80 mph curve is his best pitch. He’d have to have pinpoint command. Maxxed out 89 FB.

PirateRican21

Wow Gonzales, you couldn’t look worse.

TNBucs

I agree with Walker that there should be more SBs but the effect of the new base size at 1B should be neutralized by also shortening the distances of throws.

1979andCounting

Zas LH reliever: decent curve ball, big spread from 80 – 93 mph.

1979andCounting

Two poor throws by Cal. No foot speed.
I don’t know how he makes the 26.

EightMenOut

Davis just keeps his shoulder in place and accepts getting hit by the curve, that is really on him.

b mcferren

hbp

nice elbow guard

1979andCounting

Ok now we’ve seen Smith-njibja arm. Weak.

1979andCounting

First chance for Peggy and he can’t make the 70′ throw to Endy…..his woes start right where they left off.

b mcferren

we´re not playing any games against the NL Central???

EightMenOut

Grapefruits and Cacti don’t mix

b mcferren
b mcferren

I like the stirrups on chavez young

b mcferren

why on earth did they spend so much money on underwood, stephenson and de jong through arbitration?

b mcferren

Joe is a well spoken dude

1979andCounting

And is not a fan of the clock at all

b mcferren

I dont think any of these dudes like it and all of them were told if they don´t say nice things about it on camera, then they will be fined

1979andCounting

They’re professionals who have honed their skills along with the mental approach needed to be their best. And now a ticking clock interrupts all of that skill and craft.

b mcferren

the game was never meant to be played like an nba jam video game

EightMenOut

The average baseball game in the 1960’s and 1970’s took 2 hours and 30 minutes. So the pitch clock is making it more traditional. The last forty years there has been a lot of huffing and adjustments between every pitch that was just boring.

TNBucs

Plus, traditionalists got their shift ban, so call it even.

1979andCounting

I think shifts should stay. It’s dumb mandating two on each side of second. But MLB wants more offense.

TNBucs

I agree, but I’ve heard traditionalists say they don’t like shifts.

TNBucs

Old men complaining about the pitch clock while knocking the NBA is only going to reinforce MLB’s thinking that it’s a good idea. (I’m old too, so not a knock on anyone in particular.)

b mcferren

why do they think they are going to convert NBA fans away?

TNBucs

It’s not about converting but connecting with the short attention span generations. Now if they’d just shorten their commercial breaks.

b mcferren

just make a different game

its getting close to the point where people who want to watch “baseball” would support watching a different league

Born4rf

Love a real game day! On the Brubaker topic, it surprises me to see so much negatively about JTB. His numbers last year were roughly similar to Charlie Morton’s seventh season, when we cast him off (but I’m sure yinz all knew better, huh) Much better than Charlie’s third season… By miles! JT has a good career trajectory right now and seems ready for a break out.

sewer2001

Agreed! While you’re at it, look at Verlander a first four seasons and compare to Keller. Yes. Do it. He struck out 7.5 per 9 before his breakout. A lot of fans seem to think stars never have to struggle a bit. That’s just not how it works.

EightMenOut

Endy the first sub in, nice

Scam likely

Bullpen in mid-season form

PirateRican21

Been saying it all offseason, this is a bad bullpen, mainly because they don’t strike anybody out, bunch of contact arms.

1979andCounting

Let the LH reliever competition begin. I want to see them all!

1979andCounting

Scouting report: tops out at 92 FB but he’s got good offspeed stuff. Knows how to pitch, moves the ball around.

PiratePrimate

The Pitch Clock is wonderful!

b mcferren

this pitch clock is stupid

who is asking for this? the janitor who cleans the popcorn after the game?

1979andCounting

Yep not a fan either.

SouthernBuc

I don’t like the thought of the pitch clock, but to be honest I also am very tired of relief pitchers taking 30 seconds to mentally prepare for each pitch and for batters taking 30 seconds to adjust all parts of their armor and blindly stare at their bats for 30 seconds before they enter the batters box.

I get the game is hard but at some point I think players who can ‘grip and rip it’ need to be rewarded. They need to be able to recall a scouting report or get prepared in a few seconds, that is how the game should be played.

Last edited 1 month ago by SouthernBuc
b mcferren

this commissioner just needs to go start his on XFL league with vince mcmahon

can take all the stats nerds a statcast cameras with him

good riddance to all this crap

EightMenOut

Neither is Garcia

Scam likely

Our closer getting clobbered

EightMenOut

Bednar making Keller look good.

TNBucs

Understatement of the year: After the first HR, Walker (who I really like as a broadcaster) reassured us that “it’s still early.”

b mcferren

no moar Burbaker plz

EightMenOut

Suwinski, new stance, same results against left-handers.

Scam likely

19 swings 30 rbi’s last year ,the rest of his swings 8 rbi’s.

PiratePrimate

Zach and Rudy were buddies last year so he threw Rudy a cookie

EightMenOut

Castro, 1 pitch, grand slam, I’m ok with that.

1979andCounting

There’s our starting 2B man on Opening Day!! Grand Slam!

b mcferren

best second baseman in the NL central

1979andCounting

I like India a lot.

1979andCounting

Ex-Pirate on the mound….Zach Thompson

1979andCounting

Santana! Nice stretch and pick.

1979andCounting

That’s an E-9 on Joe

1979andCounting

That Andujar throw……??? What has he been doing for 10 days?

Scrappy2499

Andujar has a weak arm, two horrible throws supposedly towards the catcher.

Last edited 1 month ago by Scrappy2499
EightMenOut

really liking the pitch clock, the game moves along without so much dead time.

James_Robert5

Yeah it made a noticeable difference at minor league games last year

Plus this one in the win column for Rob M

TNBucs

I’m a bit surprised about how much faster the game feels.

1979andCounting

It’s the lack of making contact lol not the clock!

1979andCounting

Hedges hitting 5th? Funny. Didn’t take long for Shelton antics.

EightMenOut

That lineup is full of opening day players, on the first day of spring training, nice.

1979andCounting

Santana 1B, Bae 2B, Cruz, Castro 3B, Andujar LF, Jack CF, Joe RF, Hedges C is our starters.

Share article

Pirates Prospects Daily

Latest articles

Pirates Prospects Weekly

MONDAY: First Pitch

TUESDAY: Article Drop

WEDNESDAY: Opinions

THURSDAY: Roundtable

FRIDAY: Discussion

SATURDAY: Pirates Draft Report

SUNDAY: Pirates Business

Latest comments

68
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x