First Pitch: Pirates Prospects and the Pittsburgh Pirates Universe

On the middle of a white page with blue striped lines, there is a black dot which represents the singularity that is the Pittsburgh Pirates organization.

Surrounding this dot is everything, and nothing at all.

That’s mostly because I had something else to do that day, and I ended up not filling in the rest of the page in my work notebook.

However, let’s say that this dot represents the singularity in the middle of the black hole that sits in the center of the Pittsburgh Pirates’ universe. That description sometimes feels very apt when it comes to finding information about this franchise. It’s often a mystery what goes on inside the Pirates’ organization, and finding out is often as difficult as seeing the singularity in the center of an actual black hole.

Surrounding such a black hole would be stars, planets, and every being who knows of the existence of the Pittsburgh Pirates. Let me tell you, as an owner of one of the planets in this universe, the size of this universe is nearly impossible for any human brain to fathom.

If this were a universe, Pirates Prospects would be a planet.

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette would be a bigger planet. and The Athletic would each be their own planet.

DK Pittsburgh Sports would be a planet.

Some of those planets operate on a Multiversial level, where their planet exists across multiple “galaxies” (the Steelers and Penguins are their own galaxies of information in Pittsburgh). Others, like Pirates Prospects, exist in a single galaxy, rather than being Nexus entities that you can find across the Pittsburgh sports Multiverse.

Let’s say that the Pittsburgh Pirates’ galaxy allows for easier space travel than our own real-life Milky Way galaxy. You don’t need to travel light-years to go from The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Pirates coverage to this site. In fact, you can make a home on both planets.

There are millions and millions of people who live inside the Pirates’ galaxy. Some of them were born here. Some of them are visiting from other galaxies. Some of you live on this planet called Pirates Prospects. There are some who would fling an asteroid into the center of this planet if they could. And some people are just visiting. Maybe they live in the Cincinnati Reds galaxy, and stumbled over here through a wormhole created when Ben Cherington traded Kevin Newman for Dauri Moreta. Maybe they exist in a different dimension of this universe, focused on fantasy sports or gambling, and they’re aiming to extract information from this planet.

I’m going to stop with the quantum parallels and tell you what I’m talking about without you having to dissect the singularity of this idea hidden in the black hole of my mind.

This website is very popular. In fact, it’s too popular for my comfort. The impact of running a popular site like this for so long is that I can’t go anywhere without running into a Pirates fan who has heard of me or my site. That’s not to say that every Pirates fan has heard of me or this site. That would be impossible with the massive size of this galaxy.

I say this site is popular, which means it draws a lot of traffic. This year, in a year where I did minimal promotion of the site (ask Ethan Hullihen how many times he had to ask me to tweet out links this year), and the site will still end up with over half a million unique visitors. Those are actual people. Next year, I’m projecting at least seven million pages viewed on this site. That’s a different stat that can be monetized.

There are two main ways that I can monetize this site: Get the masses to each pay a small amount, or get a small amount of people to pay a larger amount.

From 2009-2014, this site took the former approach. We relied on ads. The site had more than ten million page views in the final two years, before we switched to a subscription site. I couldn’t grow the site on the ad-only model, but it could survive as a small planet in the Pirates’ galaxy.

Once we switched to a subscription model, we still had a few hundred thousand people visiting this “planet”, but only a few thousand people “lived” on it — aka, they paid for and were able to access articles. Those were our subscribers who supported us enough to allow this site to expand to where I can confidently call it a planet in the Pittsburgh Pirates’ galaxy. My estimate is that we had over 10,000 subscribers from 2015-22, with a reduced paywall from 2019-22.

My recent move to take down the site’s paywall was an attempt to open the site to everyone in the Pirates’ universe.

This weekend, I put advertisements on the site for the first time since 2018. Over the next month, my plan will be to adjust these in order to best monetize the masses. If we have seven million page views next year, then the advertisements we will show will pay for the base level of this site.

From there, we would still need supporters in order to grow and operate in the way that is unique to this “planet” in this “galaxy”. In the past, we had regular reports from all of the Pirates’ affiliates, along with reporters in Pittsburgh.

Essentially, we can have all of that with advertising alone. But, you can’t have me and all of that with advertising. One way of looking at the current model is that advertising will pay for the site and contributions will pay for me. But in reality, it’s all one lump sum, and my only monetary focus is on personal survival.

This year, I’ve gotten this site to the point where I can run it almost like a part-time job. At the bare minimum, this site could exist forever with minimal producing each week on my end. It would run much like you saw during the 2022 season. The advertisements would help to pay for everyone else’s contributions, but I would be looking to make my money elsewhere.

I don’t want to leave this site for good, or have a reduced role forever. I want to make it very clear that I have the luxury to make this move. I’ve been saving up so that this site could survive without me for a period of time while I write my Time Travelers vs Vampires series. I want to make that very clear, because there are people right now who are trying to make their own planet inside the Pittsburgh Pirates’ galaxy. I have the luxury of leaving my existing planet to try and create an entire universe that doesn’t exist in the grand Multiverse we know as life.

At this point, this site could survive at least one more year without advertisements or subscriptions. Maybe more than that if I moved to a cheap, remote area like the area where I grew up in Virginia, rather than living in Florida or Pittsburgh. The point is, the site has stability that has allowed me to play around with how the site makes money. My role on this site is to push that Doomsday date as far into the future as possible.

This is done simply by adding revenue. Advertisements will ensure that this site will always be around.

Contributions from our readers will allow us to grow and provide the best coverage.

We are going to need both in order to turn Pirates Prospects into the outlet I know it can become.

For the next month, have patience as I play around with the ad model. Eventually, anyone who donates to the site will have access to the clean, ad-free model, which I prefer. Anyone who has donated in the past will be grandfathered in appropriately. Before that happens, I need a bit of a baseline on how the advertisements will perform.

I’m saying all of this with the disclaimer that I don’t need to say anything. I could throw advertisements up with no explanation. I could put the entire site behind the paywall and make it so that only those who pay can experience our work. I know that either one of those approaches will work in terms of keeping this site going. The site could survive, even if I gave zero explanation as to what I’m doing.

My goal is to find the best hybrid approach to allow for the most people to access our work, while generating the most revenue possible for that work. The good thing is that I’m a simple man. Give me an ounce of weed, a few new albums, and some Sci-fi stories and I’m content in life for at least a few weeks. I’m not someone who is driven by money or possessions, so the more money this site makes, the bigger it can grow and the more I can give to other creators working on this site.

This weekend’s addition of advertisements on the site was a big step toward the site’s long-term growth plans.

Next week on First Pitch, I’ll discuss our books and the merchandise store I’ll be launching on this site in the next year, which will further help toward this goal. For now, here’s a rundown of what was on the site last week, and what is to come next week.


The Pirates were busy during the holiday week last week, adding Carlos Santana as a free agent. I wrote last Wednesday how they lack the essential experience to contend. Santana, who agreed to terms two days later, will definitely bring that experience.

Last week on the site we went heavy on prospect coverage, which makes a lot of sense, considering the nature of this site. On Tuesday, we released features on five players:

**Jared Jones: Learning To Trust Stuff Through Development Process

**Nick Garcia: Simplified Approach In Work As A Starter

**The Mystery of Dauri Moreta’s Sinker

**Noe Toribio Sees Growth As a Reliever

**John O’Reilly Finished Strong After Rollercoaster Season

Wilbur Miller looked at breakout candidates for the Pirates’ Single-A affiliate in 2023. In our latest Roundtable, we identified second half surges that we’re buying from the 2022 season. John Dreker profiled right-handed pitcher Osvaldo Bido in the latest Pirates Winter Report.

Wrapping up the week, Ethan Hullihen looked at the Pirates’ odds of getting the first pick in the 2023 draft under the new MLB Draft lottery.


We’ve got a few player updates, as well as reactions to all of the first base moves that will go up in tomorrow’s article drop. As the week goes on, we’ll be focusing more on the upcoming Winter Meetings, and we will be shifting toward the upcoming release of our prospect rankings.


This week’s playlist is heavy on Carlos Santana. I also went with some Jimi Hendrix and Led Zeppelin, since a lot of my music tastes were shaped by listening to the guitar work of these acts.

I also went heavy with some Latin American artists, including Buena Vista Social Club and Luis Miguel.

I usually throw in some new music. This week’s new album is “Working on My Karma” by dvsn.


I got every pick after 1986. My Pirates knowledge falls apart before that time. Post your score in the comments below.


Pirates Prospects has always been fueled 100% by reader support — whether through a high traffic site that relied on ads, or a full paywall that was supported by over 10,000 subscribers between 2015-2022. With no more paywall, the site is free for everyone. All I ask is that you Contribute at some point in the future to help support our work. We’re not going to impose any pricing limits, content restrictions, or timelines on anyone. We just hope that you enjoy the site and check back often!


Have any issues with the site or your account? Check out our Help page.

Tim started Pirates Prospects in 2009 from his home in Virginia, which was 40 minutes from where Pedro Alvarez made his pro debut in Lynchburg. That year, the Lynchburg Hillcats won the Carolina League championship, and Pirates Prospects was born from Tim's reporting along the way. The site has grown over the years to include many more writers, and Tim has gone on to become a credentialed MLB reporter, producing Pirates Prospects each year, and will publish his 11th Prospect Guide this offseason. He has also served as the Pittsburgh Pirates correspondent for Baseball America since 2019. Behind the scenes, Tim is an avid music lover, and most of the money he gets paid to run this site goes to vinyl records.

Support Pirates Prospects

Related articles

join the discussion

Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Wilbur Miller

I like the idea, but I don’t like how baseball savant thinks his most similar pitcher based on velocity and movement is 2020 Wil Crowe…


But Gibson’s control (and I bet his command) is much better.


Yeah, I actually like him as a little bit of a deep value bet to rebound, especially some peripherals. Just saying being compared to having same stuff as Wil Crowe isn’t the best comp is all.


Personally, I would pay to NOT see ads.


Did you read the article? If you paid before you won’t see ads and I’m guessing that you will be able to pay now to not see them. Ask Tim how.


I skimmed the article, see below for my response to Tim. And, I was just making a general statement. And, like Roberto, I am a paying subscriber now.


Well, I am a subscriber and I still see some ads.


Ads version is not bad at all. They do not overload the page and they don’t pop up in the middle of the article like other sites do.

80 on the quiz, pitchers and 1st basemen seemed to do me in.


As I told John….with my eyes, I have to skim articles. Perhaps, I should quit commenting. I seem to be missing more and more stuff now.


So long as it doesn’t turn into an SB Nation site with all the ads, feel free to throw a few at me. Best of luck with your series! The donation dollars will be freed up in the New Year when we get on the other side of the holidays.

Oh, can you try to get rid of the dating ads lol. I was scanning the site on the phone last night and an Asian Date Finder ad came up. Cookie me and serve me targeted ads that won’t get me castrated by the other half 🙂


yo i love your writing skills & get the analogy, but I’m cringing at the planet talk & want to help. planets/space are just fake cartoons playing on ppl’s imagination bro.

Sounds crazy if you’ve never been told this, but theres no spinning balls with curved water traveling millions of mph thru space. We live on a plane that’s level with varying elevations & non-moving just as we perceive with our eyes & would know if it weren’t for ppl of authority telling us elsewise & showing us bs cartoons.

FWIW Planets are what the ancients referred to as Wandering Stars, as they are colored stars that take different geometric paths in the sky than the Fixed Stars (the constellations that have stayed in the same patterns for as long as we know)

Scam likely

Yea kind of like baseball analytics lol


Are you saying the earth is flat? Are you a Carl Everett fan? Former MLB Outfielder for the Red Sox and other teams. He believes that the earth is flat. He also believes dinosaurs and humans roamed the earth together. Doesn’t make it true.


can’t spell believe without lie. i’m that guy that gets pissed off at parents for fooling their kids about santa. i don’t believe in anything, i know because I have proven with 100% geometric accuracy what i’m sharing.

lol don’t get me started on the dino lies too!


Like always, well thought out & written. You have an amazing mind


The analogy in the article worked well, but I still find myself wondering if Tim came up with the idea right after smoking LOL.


Vampires and time travelers, Jesus wept, color me interested!


When the 1st one’s done, I’ll get it catalogued for my library, make you bona fide in the Dewey world!


I will ask to please, please do not saturate it with ads, I can’t spend hardly anytime at FG without my tablet crashing and other pirates site have so many ads that I barely bother to visit.


I pay FG and it still irritates me that I see ads. I am dropping the Athletic because of Ads.


Good to read! Thanks!

Wilbur Miller

Maybe we can also avoid the “Find Asian Women” type ad systems.

Bucs'N'Pucks (Jeff Reed)

*clears browsing history*


Waitaminnit! How come EYE don’t see those??!!


You just -hadda- put “Smooth” on there, didn’t you?

John Dreker

Got a 98 on the quiz with just under a minute left. Could have done better, but apparently I mis-typed a name and got it the second time I tried because I couldn’t think of anyone else it could be. That cost me some time.


You’re smarter than I thought you were. Not a high bar, of course. 🙂

Old Man Foo

Share article

Pirates Prospects Daily

Latest articles

Pirates Prospects Weekly

MONDAY: First Pitch

TUESDAY: Article Drop


THURSDAY: Roundtable

FRIDAY: Discussion

SATURDAY: Pirates Winter Report

SUNDAY: Pirates Business

Latest comments

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x