25.6 F
Monday, December 5, 2022

2016 Indianapolis Indians Season Preview and Top 10 Prospects

Outside of the big league club, there is no doubt that Indianapolis has the most talented squad in the entire organization. Top to bottom at every position, the team is loaded with prospects. This is especially true with the starting rotation. Tyler Glasnow is one of the top pitching prospects in the game, while Jameson Taillon was up there as well before he was derailed by Tommy John surgery in 2013. Chad Kuhl got a taste of Triple-A with a postseason start for Indianapolis, capping a breakout season. Steven Brault rivaled the coming out party that Kuhl saw in 2015, and showed what a steal the Travis Snider trade was. Trevor Williams comes over from the Marlins as compensation for losing Jim Benedict, and helps round out the rotation.

On offense, Josh Bell is viewed as one of the top pure hitting prospects across the game. He will now be in his second full season as a first baseman, and there are still occasional growing pains which is the main thing standing between him and Pittsburgh. The offensive game is polished despite Bell displaying more power from the left side of the plate.

Elias Diaz will be the featured catcher once he returns from an elbow ailment. Last season, Diaz split time behind the plate with Tony Sanchez, but this year he will see the bulk of the time at catcher. Joining Diaz, Alen Hanson returns to Indianapolis for his second season at the level. Inconsistency and learning a new position were the themes for Hanson in 2015. It is difficult for any hitter at any level to rival the May that Hanson had last season, but he got off to a slow start and finished the season cold. Additionally, Hanson saw time at third base to go along with second last season, which is expected to continue into 2016.

Willy Garcia will return to Indianapolis after joining the squad toward the middle of last season. After getting off to a slow start himself, Garcia got hot down the stretch for at Triple-A and showed the promise that he has at the plate with power, along with a strong outfield arm that had him near the league leaders in outfield assists. Gift Ngoepe joined the team toward the middle of the season as well, and continued to show his defensive prowess at shortstop. The fact that neither player cracks the top 10 prospects at the level just speaks to the true depth.

After strong campaigns with Altoona last season, Max Moroff and Adam Frazier join the Indianapolis squad this season. This leads to the biggest question for Dean Treanor: where do you fill all of these prospects in on a daily basis?

2016 Indianapolis Indians Top 10 Prospects

1. Tyler Glasnow, RHP – While Glasnow is one of the top pitching prospects in the game, he still has some work to do at the level. Glasnow battled an ankle injury with Altoona, but returned and dominated the level with improved control, earning him a mid-season promotion to Indianapolis. After getting off to a strong start with Indianapolis in his first couple of outings, Glasnow really struggled with command and the results suffered. Though he was able to work his way out of some innings due to his stuff, getting more command out of his off-speed pitches is key to his development, as is his consistency at the level. In one outing, Glasnow was only able to retire one hitter, allowing six runs on five walks. However, that was not his season high in walks at the level, as he allowed six free passes in 4.2 innings in his second start.

Despite the issues he needs to work on, Glasnow has plus-plus velocity with his fastball and a plus breaking ball when it is going right. There are big things expected of the tall righty in 2016, after showing some flashes last season. Having some time at Triple-A under his belt should help to calm the nerves that we saw last season. He also needs to improve throwing the curveball for strikes early in the count, to keep hitters from sitting on the fastball. Glasnow could be up in Pittsburgh in the second half of the 2016 season.

2. Josh Bell, 1B – There is no questioning Bell’s ability at the plate. The switch-hitter has skills beyond his young years, even though his game at the plate is constantly evolving. This is proof by the changes with his leg kick over the past year, leading to better offense, and finally tapping into his raw power. Bell hit .347 in 121 at bats with Indianapolis last season after earning a promotion from Altoona. The only thing that is not fully polished for Bell is the power, hitting just seven home runs in 489 at bats last season. While the home runs have not shown through just yet, Bell did have 24 doubles and nine triples in 2015 for a .838 OPS between Altoona and Indianapolis.

The offensive game is clearly nearing big league ready, with Bell’s swing looking smoother than ever from both sides, rather than the two-part awkward swing he showed from the right side in the past. The main question with Bell is his adaptation to playing first base. This will be his second full season at the position. While there were some expected headaches early, and they will continue to appear, Bell looked much more comfortable in the role coming into the year, and will need to continue that development this season.

3. Jameson Taillon, RHP – Coming off two of the most frustrating seasons he has seen, Taillon looks to bounce back strong in 2016 with Indianapolis. After having Tommy John surgery at the beginning of 2014, Taillon missed that entire season. When he was just about to return last season, he endured a sports hernia that resulted in him being shut down again. For Taillon, 2016 is about finally making the jump to the majors that he was projected to make in each of the previous two years.

Prior to the injury, Taillon appeared in six games with Indianapolis, posting a 3.89 ERA, while averaging a strikeout per inning. He also walked 16 hitters in 37 innings, and allowed 31 hits. His stuff, post surgery, is much better, with the best and easiest mechanics he’s shown in his career. Taillon’s stuff is Major League ready. This spring, the fastball life is back, as Taillon is in the mid-90s, while the rest of his stuff appears crisp as he looks for a strong 2016 campaign. The one thing he will need before arriving in the majors is experience against upper level hitters, working on his pitch sequencing, and polishing everything off after two years with no time against upper level hitting. He should make the jump to Pittsburgh in the second half.

4. Alen Hanson, 2B – Hanson is traditionally a slow starter, and showed that again last season in Indianapolis, hitting just .234 in April with one extra base hit. He rebounded in May with one of the best months that anyone could have, posting a .998 OPS with a .362 average. During the month, he had eight doubles, five triples, and three home runs. That success was short-lived. Hanson returned to hitting .206 in a June that saw him only pick up 13 total hits. Additionally, he topped only .600 OPS in one month the rest of the season. Hanson clearly has the tools at the plate and speed on the base paths, stealing 35 bases in 2015. It is just about putting it all together and sustaining consistency.

Hanson also changed positions last season, moving from shortstop to second base, which led to better consistency on the field. This year he will primarily play second base, but will get some time at third, short, and a start a week in the outfield. While mistakes do still occasionally happen defensively, Hanson looked like a better fit at second with his arm and range, and profiles as a future starter at the position with the Pirates. He should be the top option if the Pirates need an infielder from Triple-A, especially if they need a starting option.

5. Elias Diaz, C – The 2016 season is already off to a rough start for Diaz, who was shut down at the end of Spring Training with elbow soreness. Fortunately, he won’t need surgery. Similar to Hanson, Diaz saw a tough April at the plate with Indianapolis in 2015. He hit just .203 with a .559 OPS. However, opposite of Hanson, Diaz was consistent the remainder of the season at the plate. Diaz has sneaky and developing power that does not necessarily show up in the stats. While he had just four home runs for the season, Diaz also had 16 doubles and four triples in 325 at bats.

With Tony Sanchez gone, Diaz will be the everyday catcher at the level once he returns from the injury. With the crowded position last season, Diaz split time behind the plate with Sanchez fairly evenly. This didn’t impact his defense, where he is clearly polished, but made it difficult for him to excel offensively. He has one of the strongest arms at catcher, works well with the pitching staff, and is regarded as one of the best defensive catchers in minor league baseball. It is all about how the offensive game continues to develop. He will be the top backup option in Pittsburgh when he’s healthy, with the chance to be the starter in 2017.

6. Chad Kuhl, RHP – Kuhl got an opportunity to get his feet wet with Indianapolis last season in a championship playoff series start, after a strong season with Altoona. The right-hander did not disappoint in the game either, going seven inning and allowing just one run on six hits against the eventual International League champion. Prior to that, with Altoona, Kuhl was basically unhittable in the second half of 2015. He posted a 1.38 ERA with a WHIP under 1.00 after July 1 in Double-A. Additionally, he saw an uptick in velocity. While the sinker was sitting around 94, he was also touching 97 at times over the span.

After experiencing some minor soreness in Spring Training, Kuhl was set back from the other starters and will miss the beginning of the season. Expected to miss just a couple of starts, Kuhl will jump into the Indianapolis rotation toward the middle of April. Combining the velocity with the downward movement that Kuhl gets with the sinker makes that a devastating pitch. He will need an out pitch to pair with the sinker, and has been improving his slider in the last year. Kuhl could be an option for the big leagues this year, and projects as a guy who could be a number four starter in the future, with the chance to be a number three if the slider improves to above-average.

7. Steven Brault, LHP – After a breakout 2015 season, Brault will make the jump to the Indianapolis rotation in 2016. After getting off to a slow start in his first three outings with Bradenton last season, it was hard to find anyone in the organization as successful as Brault. With that success, he earned a promotion to Altoona after 13 starts. Brault limited solid contact most of the season in Altoona, keeping all but one pitch inside the yard in 90 innings. He also held left-handed hitters to just a .401 OPS.

While he doesn’t have the explosive stuff as some of the other starters, the former player to be named in the Travis Snider deal gets by with movement, deception, and location. Brault’s bread and butter is a sinker that hits in the high 80s and has late cutting movement. He has improved a four seam fastball that reaches 93. A slider and a changeup are also in his arsenal, although the slider is a new focus, aimed at finally getting him an out pitch. The 2016 season will be a key for Brault to build on the success of 2015, and could have him in the talks for a future rotation spot in Pittsburgh.

8. Max Moroff, 2B – With his promotion to Indianapolis, it appears that Moroff is going to get the opportunity to play a few different positions with the crowded infield at the level. After a marginal 2014 season at the plate, Moroff still saw a promotion to Altoona in 2015. While there, he enjoyed a breakout campaign, hitting .293 with a .783 OPS. Moroff also added 28 doubles and seven home runs in 523 at-bats last season. He added more power as the season went along last year, but his strikeout numbers also went up consequently. How he progresses with the power, while balancing the average, will be a nice story line for Moroff in 2016.

Moroff will spend most of his time at third base this season, while also getting some starts at second when Alen Hanson is playing elsewhere. He has played shortstop in the past, but won’t get a lot of time at the position. He could also learn the outfield at some point, to add more flexibility. His path to the majors in the future is as a utility player, and he could help out in 2016 as a depth option for the bench.

9. Trevor Williams, RHP – Williams was acquired in a lopsided trade by the Pirates from the Marlins, and it was reported later that it was compensation for losing Jim Benedict. Williams works with both a four-seam and two-seam fastball that each sits in the low 90s, but has touched as high as 97 in the past. Williams also will go to his changeup more often than a breaking ball. He throws a curve and a slider, although the slider is the pitch that he was working heavily on in the spring. While he doesn’t strike out a ton of hitters, Williams is effective at keeping the ball on the ground and getting outs by pitching to contact.

In 2015, Williams got an opportunity to get his feet wet in Triple-A, posting a 2.57 ERA in just 14 innings in the Marlins organization. Control was occasionally an issue for Williams last season, as his walk numbers did go up. Improving the slider as an out pitch and getting back to controlling his sinker are the keys to the right-hander with Indianapolis this season. He’s another guy who could be rotation depth in Pittsburgh down the line, or could help out in the bullpen.

10. Adam Frazier, 2B – Adam Frazier saw a breakout season with Altoona at the plate last year, and just missed out on the Eastern League batting crown by a technicality. Frazier had one huge month, hitting .424 in June, and while he didn’t match that going forward, he maintained consistency the rest of the year, as in his worst month he still had a .283 average. Frazier is very limited on his power, but does have the ability to go gap-to-gap and compiled 21 doubles in 377 at-bats last season.

Though he is a natural shortstop, Frazier will likely be moving around a lot this season. He could see time at second and short, while other players take a day off, but the outfield looks like a more likely spot for Frazier in Indianapolis this season. While it will be difficult for Frazier to repeat the success of 2015 completely, if he is able to have a strong campaign, he could certainly get himself into the conversation of an eventual bench spot with the Pirates. He’s a future super utility player, with value due to his ability to play short in a backup role, and his ability to play left and center field.

Other Notable Prospects

Nick Kingham would be included in this list, but it’s doubtful that he will return to Indianapolis at all this season, as he rehabs from Tommy John surgery. He’s mentioned here because there is no other place to list him in the season previews, and we didn’t want to leave a top ten prospect out of the previews. Willy Garcia and Gift Ngoepe are two of the top 50 prospects in the system, but don’t even make the top 10 list in Indianapolis, showing off the depth at this level. Garcia has the best outfield arm in the minor league system, and some of the best raw power, but struggles with his strikeouts and doesn’t hit for average on a consistent basis. Ngoepe is the strongest defensive shortstop in the system, and has a lot of speed, but doesn’t hit enough with the bat to make him more than a backup in the majors. Both could be depth options at some point this year. Jacob Stallings is another notable prospect at the level. He starts the season as the number three catcher on the MLB depth chart with Elias Diaz injured, but would drop back to being a backup in Indianapolis when Diaz returns. Long-term, he comps to Chris Stewart, with the chance to be a backup catcher in the majors due to his defense and work with the pitchers. Dan Gamache just missed our top 50 prospect list, and just misses on starting in Indianapolis this year. He would be a starter at any other level, but will be a bat off the bench, playing first, second, and third throughout the year. He could have a shot at being a utility guy in the majors one day.

+ posts

Ryan has been following Indianapolis baseball for most of his life, and the Pirates since they became the affiliate in 2005. He began writing for Pirates Prospects in 2013, in a stint that ran through 2016 (with no service time manipulation played in). Ryan rejoined the team in 2022, covering Indianapolis once again. He has covered the Pirates in four different big league stadiums. Ryan was also fortunate enough to cover the 2015 Futures Game in Cincinnati.


Pirates Prospects has been independently owned and operated since 2009, entirely due to the support of our readers. The site is now completely free, funded entirely by user support. By supporting the site, you are supporting independent writers, one of the best Pittsburgh Pirates communities online, and our mission for the most complete Pirates coverage available.

Related articles

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Harry S

Next year the Pirates should be much younger with no loss of talent, assuming many of the players at Indy are ready to step up. S-Rod, Figueroa, Joyce, and Morse will probably not be back. It’s doubtful Locke makes it through this season. Just curious, where does Jason Rogers fit in the mix? I assume he doesn’t qualify as a prospect but he might play a part on the Pirates this year.

Blaine Huff

I could see your scenario being the case if the Pirates commit to the prospects.

Pitchers: Cole, Liriano, Glasnow, Taillon…no need for Locke or Niese…or maybe even Nicasio with Brault, Kuhl, and Williams knocking on the door.

Figgy? Hanson could replace that spot.
Joyce? Garcia.
Morse? Rogers.
S-Rod? Frazier or Moroff.
Freese? The other half of Frazier/Moroff.

If the Pirates do well this year, it will be interesting to see what happens between seasons. In spite of what a lot of folks think…Locke has some trade value, if Niese rebounds he’s cheap enough to be worth a couple of decent guys, and Nicasio has the opportunity to build a lot of trade worth.

The BP should be a fun watch…Melancon is gone after this season…and I’ve gotta wonder whether the Pirates throw Watson an extension…4/30 seems about right.

Cervelli is out…Diaz and Stewwy should be holding down the fort next season.

And, of course, there’s always Cutch to consider…


I would say your view will be close but this doesn’t feel like the Pirates way. I think they will hedge their bets a little. I would think (assuming no injuries) they are more likely to go into 2017 with:
– rotation of Cole, Liriano, Taillon, Glasnow & Niese/Locke/Nicasio that would give them the NGTs, Kingham and Holmes as back ups (the ten that Neal likes to have)
– bullpen they may need to spend money for a late inning reliever but they could use some of the starting depth here
– lineup same Except 1B and C could probably be Bell and Diaz (unless Cervelli resigns)
– bench would be Stewart, Jaso, Hanson, Frazier, and Rogers


I can’t remember ever disagreeing with you, let alone literally every single post you’ve made in this thread. 😉 That’s fun!

Blaine Huff

Well then, in that case I’m going to make a post that says “NMR is awesome”…

…and let’s see how long it takes you to edit the above.

🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂

What I was trying to get across with the above might have been better said as:

“There’s enough talent at AAA this season that, with another year of development, the 2016 bench could be replaced by it next season.”

As for the SPs…that’ll be interesting…we’ve had the conversation before…how do you break young pitchers in while staying competitive? I dunno…but I think we’re about to see it attempted.


It was really the details I disagreed with; I’m very much with you guys on the bench, or at least most of it, being replaced internally.


Kingham will pitch 70+ innings in Indy this year. Book it.

Tim Williams





Snider for Brault and Tarpley…that’s one for the ages.
I think before the WC game was even over last year I was already thinking about the lineup Indy would be running out to start the season. This will probably be as close as I ever follow a minor league team. Can’t wait to see the contributions some of these guys bring.

Blaine Huff

I really, really, really, really want to agree with you, but Snider hit 3 HRs and put a .659 OPS with the O’s.

That doesn’t sound impressive at all, but it is infinitely more than Brault and Tarpley have contributed to the Pirates.

I love me some Brault, but, until these guys actually contribute, the value of the trade is still up in the air.

michael t

and don’t forget how bad our OF bench and pinch hitting was at the beginning of the year without Snider


If you want to freeze time right now and just look at results then yes that’s true. I’d prefer to judge things like this on the process in which case Im comfortable saying it was a great move.

Blaine Huff

No disagreement that it will probably turn out to be a great move.

I’m just waiting to see that it does before agreeing…sort of like the Bay trade…where every expert in the word claimed the Pirates won it. Then, in retrospect…


Hanson will be in Pittsburgh in the 2nd half! That will allow Josh to move around and get rest!! Can’t wait to see JT pitch!! Pulling for that guy!! Jaso will keep Josh in Indy all year!!! All of them will be up in Sept for sure!!


A true top 10 list…all 10 legit prospects.


Unreal, the talent that they have coming up, though it seems some of these guys might be blocked, still a great problem to have.

Scott Kliesen

If not the best combination of ML & AAA roster in MLB, it certainly is in top 3. Pirates are in sweet spot of contention for next 3 years. Time to get ready to raise that championship Jolly Roger!


I think the window is much larger than that.


Window, maybe, but don’t discount for a second having both Gerrit Cole and Andrew McCutchen on one roster.

Scott’s right, these are two generational talents on one ballclub at incredible prices. Realistically, it’ll be decades before the Pirates have a better base from which to build a baseball team.


Maybe… Maybe not… Even if Cutch and Cole leave, the potential with Polanco, Glasnow, Taillon, etc.. is still really good. I think this team has a chance to have a solid core for a least the next half dozen years.


And Polanco, Glasnow, Tailon will still get to play for two years with Cutch and Cole. You can understand how the club is considerably better with those two players, correct???


I don’t deny that but they won’t be chopped liver without them.


Nor did anyone in this conversation say so.

Blaine Huff

Just curious…how are you defining ‘generational talent’?

I would go the literal route as in: ‘the level of talent that only comes along once in a generation,’ so you really can’t have two, simultaneously.


That’s exactly how I’d define generational talent, but in the Strasburg/Harper manner. Differentiating hitters and pitchers.

Blaine Huff

Gotcha….it’s just a hard term for me to use. Too slippery.

I.e., Cutch is the best position player we’ve had in a generation (Bonds)…okay, that really can’t be strongly debated. Hypothetically if “so-and-so prospect” joins the Pirates and is better than Cutch…is he not a ‘generational player’ because he’s a contemporary of Cutch, or is Cutch no longer a generational and this new guy is because he’s the best we’ve had since Bonds (a generation)?

I guess that’s what I’m trying to get across…this categorization is just too fuzzy and subjective a distinction.

Scott Kliesen

You can if you consider Cutch to be best position player and Cole to be best SP in a generation.



Blaine Huff

I getcha now…but it’s team specific, obviously.

I wouldn’t disagree with that assessment, so far. I’d argue that distinction more for Cutch that Cole. Cole has definitely been the best SP the Pirates have had for, at least, a decade….but there are too many arms on the horizon to know whether he’ll even be the best pitcher on the team in ’18/’19…let alone in a couple of decades. We shall see 🙂

But ‘generational talent’ is just a fuzzy term for me…it seems like something you can’t really determine until after a player’s tenure is complete and his accomplishments can be viewed retrospectively.


Doh! Didn’t even notice that wasn’t NMR that replied.

Eric Marshall

Cole is nowhere near a generational talent. He may get there but not in a pirate uniform. Generational is someone who puts the team on their back and wins playoff and championship games. Arrieta and Bumgartner from the past two years would rank ahead of Cole.

Luke S

Thats an insanely narrow definition of generational talent that ignores about 75% of a players time.

I love Bumgartner, but his one historic postseason doesnt suddenly make him a once in a generation talent.

It’d be calling Clayton Kershaw not a once in a generational talent because of the playoffs.

Scott Kliesen

I’m contending Cole is best SP Pirates have had in a generation. Have to go back to Drabek to find a better one.


Exactly, once again.

Blaine Huff

Is he? Meh, maybe. I mean…he’s been marginally better than Liriano over the last three seasons, but it’s not as if he’s been better than about fifty other pitchers I can think of off the top of my head that have played in MLB since Drabek’s heyday.

Calling someone a ‘generational player’, yet only comparing him against folks that have only played on the team he plays for discounts that he may be on a team that was historically bad…i.e., Cole.

Scott Kliesen

I can agree with that assessment. Given his age and experience, he could, and probably should, separate himself from Liriano and the rest quite significantly in the next few years.

Blaine Huff

He could…or he could implode.

Hoping not, but 2.5 years is just too soon to bestow greatness. Heck…Lincecum and Verlander…


People are just not used to having actual all stars and not Evan meek, Zach duke lol

Share article

Latest articles


Latest comments