First Pitch: Is There a Limit to How Many Projects Ray Searage Can Work With?

BRADENTON, Fl. – “Ray Searage will fix him.”

That’s the line you’ve heard after pretty much every signing this off-season. Sometimes it was in the optimistic form of liking a move because of what Ray Searage could do with a player. Sometimes it was searching for the silver lining, trying to find hope for a move that didn’t look good.

But this approach and high praise for Searage wasn’t just among the Pirates fan base. It existed around the league. Every new pitcher I’ve talked with so far has issued some sort of high praise for the work Searage has done with pitchers in the last few years. Some of this was just a simple reaction to his track record, while others asked around and got great reviews from pitchers who used to be coached by Searage.

Ryan Vogelsong was in the Pirates’ system when Searage was on the minor league side of things, so he didn’t need to ask around for opinions. He’s also a guy who is looking to bounce back from a bad season. He put up a 4.67 ERA and 4.55 xFIP last year with the Giants, after posting a 4.00 ERA/3.96 xFIP in 2014 over 184.2 innings. His numbers in 2011 and 2012 were very similar to the 2014 season.

“You have to be excited about what he’s done with the guys,” Vogelsong said. “He’s done a great job, and I’ve known Ray for a long time. He was here when I was here the last time in the minor leagues. I always enjoyed talking to him and being around him.”

In fact, Vogelsong kept the relationship going, always making it a point to say hi to Searage when the two crossed paths, such as when the Giants would play the Pirates the last few years.

“I’m excited to work with him. His track record with turning some guys around has been amazing,” Vogelsong said. “I’m always trying to get better everyday, and I feel like that’s one of the things that’s kept me around the game this long. You need to try and improve something everyday you’re out here. I’m looking forward to hearing what he has to say, and trying new things, and at the same time, just try and execute what I know. From my experience, what it comes down to is making pitches, hitting the glove, hitting locations, and really it comes down to making as many good pitches as you can. If he can help me do that more consistently, I’m all for it.”

Jon Niese is another guy who could use a bounce back. He had a 4.13 ERA/4.11 xFIP in 2015, but was a 2.0+ WAR pitcher every year from 2011-14, posting a 3.60-3.84 xFIP in most years during that stretch (along with a 3.28 xFIP in 2011). This is a case where it doesn’t seem like it would take much to get Niese back to his former self, rather than the cases in the past where the Pirates have been hoping to get players back to their one good season that happened many years ago.

“His reputation is pretty remarkable from what I’ve heard from a lot of different guys,” Niese said. “It seems like he knows his stuff. He takes his craft pretty seriously. I’m looking forward to working with him.”

Then there are the more extreme projects. Cory Luebke had a great stretch from 2010-2012, combining for a 3.25 ERA/3.21 xFIP. He has since missed the last three seasons after undergoing two Tommy John surgeries and a nerve setback last year. So this off-season, Luebke said that the Pirates were one of the first teams he brought up to his agent, after hearing advice from 2015 reclamation project Clayton Richard.

“We had some discussions on why are the Pirates doing so well getting guys that are coming off some injuries, and guys that are rejuvenating their career a little bit,” Luebke said of his talks with Richard. “What are they doing? Clayton said it’s a lot of good minds, good staff, good structure. So definitely, in my situation, that was kind of exactly what I was looking for.”

The fact that Richard had good things to say about the entire organization is a positive, since Richard did a lot of work with Jim Benedict last year, and had high praise for the work that Benedict did. It’s nice to see that this praise extended beyond just Benedict.

Then there’s Eric O’Flaherty, who used to be one of the best left-handed relievers in baseball, but suffered a few injury and mechanical issues the last few years, and had a down year in 2015. O’Flaherty said that working with Searage was a big draw to him joining the organization, after hearing about him from Jesse Chavez and Justin Wilson, with the latter coming via Brian McCann.

“I’ve seen a lot of guys that kind of hit a little bump in the road and smooth things out here,” O’Flaherty said. “That was definitely a big draw, getting a chance to work with Ray. Actually, this is one of the teams I didn’t know too many guys on, but I called around to a few guys who had come through here and worked with them. And everyone said the same thing. They said he was amazing. There wasn’t one guy who said he’s okay. Everybody said great things.”

Those aren’t the only guys who are looking for a bounce back from Searage. Juan Nicasio had a solid season in relief last year for the Dodgers, and the Pirates are most likely using him as a reliever. However, if they need early season starting depth, Nicasio is a guy they will turn to, and he hasn’t had the best results in the starting role in the past. That’s another example of Searage needing to find a way to potentially fix someone.

All of these guys eventually add up, and it makes you wonder if there’s a limit to how much Searage can do. But part of that thinking assumes Searage would be starting from scratch with each guy. As Clint Hurdle points out, the Pirates usually saw something they liked with each of the guys they bring in.

“I don’t know if there’s a limit,” Hurdle said. “I think we look at the individuals, and we believe they have a chance to bounce back. Guys we bring back we think can pop, we can help pop again. Depending on the roles that they’re in, one in the starting rotation, you might take one or two in the bullpen, and then you get some other guys to compete for opportunities. So it’s never going to be you’re going to bring in four starters hoping four are going to pop back for your rotation. I don’t think that would ever be an occasion we would look to try to fall into.”

Neal Huntington noted there is a limit, but also said it’s not just Ray Searage doing the work, while repeating the idea that the Pirates saw something indicating a bounce back.

“We’re not an 18 car garage, where we’re trying to rebuild a bunch of engines and do some body work,” Huntington said. “We need to be cognizant, and that’s where it is not just Ray. It is Ray, it’s [Euclides Rojas], it’s Scott Mitchell, it’s Stan Kyles, it’s Justin Meccage, and now Scott Elarton. But then we also need to be cognizant of taxing our performance team too much. We need to be aware of it. In each one of those cases, we believe there are strong indicators that they would have better seasons in ’16 than ’15.”

But what about the man himself? How does Ray Searage feel about having so many guys in camp who are either coming off a down year, or a few down years, or much bigger projects?

“It’s not a burden whatsoever, because this is basically what we do anyway as pitching coaches when you’re in the minor leagues,” Searage said. “You’re trying to build good deliveries, sound deliveries to make them the best pitcher they can possibly be. It doesn’t change at the Major League level.”

That’s an interesting point, and one I didn’t really consider before. Searage was a pitching coach in the minors for a long period of time, and in that role he has an entire rotation and an entire bullpen to try and develop. And that’s not counting situations like Spring Training, where you’re helping players all throughout the organization. So why would it be difficult to work with two rotation members, a few bullpen guys, and trying to squeeze something out of the non-roster invitees, especially when he has all of the minor league coaches helping out?

One misconception is that it takes a lot of time for an individual reclamation project. The fact is that Searage takes an approach where he doesn’t need to spend a lot of time with each guy.

“The amount of information that you give them, you can’t overload them, because they’ll shut you off,” Searage said. “You try to keep one or two keys. You also try to have conversations with them. But the biggest thing is building those relationships, and building that trust, and then you have an open door to make suggestions. And then they’ll try something, if they don’t like it, then they’ll move on.”

I asked Searage whether he just has quick conversations with guys, or has a longer sit-down while watching videos.

“A combination of both,” Searage said. “They’re quick conversations, but they’re also quick sitdowns. Unless there’s something that’s really dire, it shouldn’t take more than 10-15 minutes to pull up a video and say this is what I’ve seen, this is what you were doing.”

As an example, Searage might see a pitcher’s video from 2012, notice something they’re not doing now, and compare the difference with the pitcher. A lot of the development process just involves studying up on the player.

“That’s basically what it is,” Searage said. “You do your homework. Do your homework as a coach to help this guy out.”

As for whether he has to change his approach with different pitchers, Searage feels that the best way is to keep a consistent approach, so that players know where he’s coming from.

“If you’re steady, you keep your same approach. And then they see what you’re all about,” Searage said. “If you keep on trying to change with different personalities, then all of a sudden they’re not going to get a good read on you. But if you’re steady about yourself and be yourself — when I first got this job, they said ‘Just be you’, and that’s stuck on my head like an iron, and that’s what I try to do.”

Ray Searage has a busy workload this spring. But the Pirates believe that the players they brought in are on the verge of a bounce back. Searage also isn’t alone, with a lot of talented pitching coaches helping out in the organization. And a busy workload of pitchers who need development is not a foreign concept to a guy who coached minor league ball from 1994 to 2010. Most importantly, Searage genuinely doesn’t seem concerned about the amount of work he has to do, and from an outside perspective, it looks like he’s got the short meeting approach down. Now we’ll see if he can do his magic once again, as the 2016 rotation and bullpen might be his biggest challenge yet.

**Everyday, Pirates Prospects posts more analysis and information on the Pirates’ system than any other outlet. We also post information that you can’t find anywhere else, as we’re the only ones who cover this team’s minor league system live on a daily basis. You can get all of this information for our low monthly, annual, or three-year prices. Subscribe today to get the best and most in-depth Pirates coverage there is. You can also purchase the 2016 Prospect Guide for profiles on every player in the system, with book discounts for subscribers.

**The Pirates Prospects App is Now Available on Android. Download the app to get notifications whenever we post an article, along with the best way to view the site on your mobile device. The iOS version for Apple devices will be out soon.

**Pirates Notes: Jaso and Locke First Impressions, McCutchen Stealing More? Notes from today’s game, with a rough start to Jeff Locke’s new delivery, and John Jaso’s first game with the Pirates. Also, notes on Andrew McCutchen potentially stealing more this year, minor league notes, and tomorrow’s lineup.

**Jacob Stallings Goes From Future Coach to Future MLB Backup Catcher. Sean McCool writes a great article on how Jacob Stallings went from a guy who was signed to save slot money for Mark Appel, to a guy who looks like a future MLB backup catcher.

**MLB Pipeline Releases Top 30 Prospect List For Pirates. The last of the top prospect lists is here.

**Injury Updates: Jung-ho Kang Set to Increase Baseball Activities This Week. No huge updates here, but good progression from Jung-ho Kang and Cory Luebke.

**Ke’Bryan Hayes and Jordan Luplow Get Recognition at Their Position. After I wrote about them last night, Baseball America named them two of the top 20 third base prospects in the minors.

Tim started Pirates Prospects in 2009 from his home in Virginia, which was 40 minutes from where Pedro Alvarez made his pro debut in Lynchburg. That year, the Lynchburg Hillcats won the Carolina League championship, and Pirates Prospects was born from Tim's reporting along the way. The site has grown over the years to include many more writers, and Tim has gone on to become a credentialed MLB reporter, producing Pirates Prospects each year, and will publish his 11th Prospect Guide this offseason. He has also served as the Pittsburgh Pirates correspondent for Baseball America since 2019. Behind the scenes, Tim is an avid music lover, and most of the money he gets paid to run this site goes to vinyl records.

Support Pirates Prospects

Related articles

join the discussion

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Probably jumping the gun on the Jeff Locke-specific conversation, but I’m also a bit confused about his focus this winter.

Maybe I’m in the minority, but I was/is fairly optimistic about Jeff Locke in 2016. Coming off a healthy season that showed a ton of room for positive regression in which he threw the ball harder than he ever has while improving his strikeout and ground ball rates. I’ll take that guy as the #5 any day.

Removing the twist from his wind-up, which I believe is what they’re referring to when they say “simplify”, and admit to trading deception for command would leave him with a delivery much the same as he’s been using from the stretch.

He’s also been really, really bad from the stretch. Harder contact, far fewer whiffs, and ironically, much worse control. I can buy an argument that believes more consistency may improve his work from the stretch, but how much might he be giving up from the wind-up?


From a purely mechanical viewpoint that twist has a lot of things that can go wrong, and I think they’re right for taking it out. I think even without the twist, wind ups in general have better velocity, control, and comfort for a pitcher. I don’t think his success from the windup correlates at all with his twist.


Possibly, but I’m not sure anything at the highest level is that simple.

We know for a fact that certain pitchers with marginal stuff rely on deception a ton, and things turn bad very quickly when they lose it; think Vance Worley and Ernesto Friari.

This is far from an exact analysis and I don’t claim for it to be more than an indicator, but the massive split in performance with bases empty vs men on base – i.e. windup vs stretch – didn’t develop until 2014, when he added the turn at the top of his leg lift.


I’ll use the same argument, guys with marginal stuff also need pinpoint command to survive in the majors. And Locke lacked the command; I think this boils down to what you think a Major League Starter needs more, deception or command.


Well done, Tim.

Obviously a healthy amount of skepticism needed; it’s not like they were going to answer “Yeah, shoot, I suppose we have overextended ourselves here”. But the info on process and timing is great.

One difference with these pitchers, specifically Niese and Vogelsong, is that nobody seems to be able to say *what* they need to do. We’ve always been able to learn something from the process with the previous successful reclamation arms, whether it was xFIP < ERA regression, plus stuff with control issues that could be worked out through mechanical improvement, change to a ground ball-heavy approach, etc. Searage Magic isn't literal; there's always been specific, targeted improvements made.

Never has "learn less hittable pitches" been an area for improvement. What is there, besides that, for Niese/Vogelsong to specifically improve? Honest question for anyone that's read otherwise or has suggestions.


Best comment I’ve seen in a while. Looking forward to the articles in response.

Bill W

In the above photo Scott Mitchell has an uncanny resemblance to AJ. When I saw it first I thought wow maybe just maybe he was coming back.


Btw, I just posted that pic on the Asylum with an “AJ is back” note.

I wonder how many will believe me?

Bill W

Asylum? The only AsylumPirates WEBSITE I am familiar with is Italian.streaming video service. What is Asylum?


I believe I said that below?

Put some tattoos on him and Scott Mitchell will look like AJ??

You even got a “Like”. Where’s MY love?
But nobody reads my posts, so that is understandable, I guess. 🙂 🙂 🙂

Bill W

Yes I did see that after I made my post. I apologize for unintentional hijacking your post. I needed a respite from my rant about Locke and Jaso. Plan A scares me — maybe the kool-aide has worn off.


My lawyer will be in touch for your blatant plagiarism.


Locke and O’Flaherty need to repeat a grade! 🙂
Seriously, there is the obvious limitation of time….he has several “projects” to work on before April 1….is that enough time to make significant progress in all or even any of them?


I just said that below about Eric O’F. 🙂

Everyone is copying my posts………sheesh.


Bill W

I basically said the same thing after the results were posted from yesterday and was criticized for lack of patience! Locke needs to wake up. On another note on MLB yesterday they talked about the Phillies and all three guys beat the living crap out of Morton.


Well, regarding Locke, its not like he has a proven track record of a good pitcher – so, I think the patience comment is irrelevant. Yes, it was his first outing, but he looked terrible. Vogelsong can only be better than that performance…

John Dreker

The good thing with some of the pitchers is that they don’t have to be ready by Opening Day, they can go to Indianapolis and work on what they have been learning. If they get back on track, then they can help the Pirates later in the season.


that is true John for some for them, but we know regarding Locke the Pirates will have him in the rotation in April even if he gets shelled all Spring – they are that stubborn at times…

Bill W

Remember Jonathan Sanchez?


You are correct Tim – they ended up being right about him…


What about that 7.13 ERA they got out of AJ during his first spring training with the club?

Is that good for the baseball? 😉

Bill W

That’s when he bunted a ball and cracked his eye socket. I am not at all as sanguine on Locke as would I have been on either Volquez or Burnett. Locke is the new Morton on this staff.


Did he also crack his eye socket the next spring, when he posted a 6.05 ERA? Did I miss that?

While I absolutely call BS on you being “sanguine” at the time about Edinson Volquez, coming off a season as the worst starting pitcher in baseball and in the midst of a spring training so bad he was sent to Extended, you *shouldn’t* be expecting Burnett-like improvements from Locke. You’ll surely be disappointed if you think every time someone works on their mechanics they’ll turn into a sub-3.50 ERA pitcher.

But you also shouldn’t freak out about the results of *any* pitcher’s first Spring Training start. Honestly, how many times does this need to be said about ST stats?

Luke S

Oh about 4-5 times a year all just before and just after the beginning of ST.


After yesterday, Eric O’F might need more hands on work? 🙂 🙂 🙂

Bill W

He is getting ready for St. Paddys Day.


Put the microscope away foo, it’s March 3rd!


Best sentence in the whole article??

**Everyday, Pirates Prospects posts more analysis and information on the Pirates’ system than any other outlet.

Bill W

Smooch Smooch


You’re just pi$$ed that you didn’t post it before me.

Bill W

How about Nutting is Cheap!


Best Pirates coverage out there, this is the best website for feeding my Pirates addiction.

dr dng

Anyone know Ray Searage’s salary?

How does it compare to other team’s pitching coaches?
How does it compare to managers?

Ok, now a pessimistic comment.
How have we been able to keep him?

John Dreker

I’ve almost never heard a coaches salary for any role, but in most cases it pales in comparison to the highest paid managers. Coaches make somewhere between $150K and less than $1M(highest I know of was $800K a few years back). This is his 14th season in the organization so I’d say he’s fairly comfortable with the Pirates


I wonder how much the Pirates will miss Jim Benedict, we will soon know. Not taking anything away from Ray Searage [he is well though off] but the Phillies a few years back made a run at JB not Ray. They wasted their time trying to hire JB as their pitching coach as he had a front office job in Pittsburgh.


Put some tattoos on him and Scott Mitchell will look like AJ??

Blaine Huff

How long is Ray under contract and are the Pirates known to be doing anything to extend him?


Why is it necessary now to rebuild Jeff Locke’s delivery since he has been on the staff for what, three years? If these changes are a help why eren’t they implemented earlier?

John Dreker

There is going to be an article on it soon, so without getting into too much detail, he’s going from a delivery that added deception, back to one that allows him to control the ball better. He’s been working on it all off-season, but this was the first game obviously.

michael t

I hope losing the deception doesn’t turn him into the “comfortable” batting practice pitcher he was yesterday.

John Dreker

We won’t get a good idea until his third or fourth start, too soon to even analyze outings


Looking forward to reading the article.


Ray Searage is a tremendous asset for the Pirates. Lots of experimentation combined with a lot of trial and error, and when the pitcher is on the same wavelength as he and his group, good things can happen.

Pirates Prospects Daily



Latest articles

Latest comments