First Pitch: The Best Thing That Happened to the Pirates Last Off-Season

The big focus this past off-season was on A.J. Burnett. The right-hander played a big role in the Pittsburgh rotation the previous two years, then after having his status up in the air for several months, he signed with the Philadelphia Phillies. There was another person who the Phillies tried to sign away from the Pirates (not Marlon Byrd, who they did sign away), and that person’s importance to the Pirates was much bigger than Burnett or any other pitcher. This person turned down the Phillies and stayed with the Pirates. His name is Jim Benedict.

The Phillies interviewed Benedict for their open pitching coach position, and came away impressed. Eventually, he turned them down, and remained in Pittsburgh as a special assistant to the General Manager, with his most important role being the work he does with pitchers in both the majors and minors.

I was thinking about Benedict on Sunday after Vance Worley’s start. As Ryan Palencer reported earlier in the season, Worley spent the first month in extended Spring Training, working with Benedict to get his mechanics back on track. It’s still early, but based on everything we’ve seen in Triple-A and his start on Sunday, Worley might be “back”, and capable of putting up numbers similar to his 2011-12 seasons. That would be a huge steal for the Pirates, since they’d control him through the 2018 season, and got him for nothing.

If Benedict was in part responsible for Worley’s turnaround, then it wouldn’t be anything new. Ray Searage gets a ton of the credit for the success with reclamation projects, but Benedict is a big part of this as well. He’s had a hand in almost every pitcher’s development in the current rotation.

The biggest one was Charlie Morton, who worked with Benedict on overhauling his game, becoming the sinkerball pitcher he is right now. Morton still works with Benedict on further adjustments, adding new pitches and working on refining old pitches. The result this year is that Morton has the best numbers in the rotation, and is looking like a solid number three starter.

Jeff Locke was a guy struggling with his command, when Benedict worked with him on adding a turn to his delivery. Since that adjustment, Locke has made the jump to the majors, and while he’s struggled at times, he still looks like he has a future in a Major League rotation. That’s a big jump from before the adjustment.

Jim Benedict working with Gerrit Cole in instructs during the 2011 season.
Jim Benedict working with Gerrit Cole in instructs during the 2011 season.

Benedict has worked with reclamation projects like Edinson Volquez and Francisco Liriano, helping Ray Searage to make certain adjustments. Every time I watched Volquez in Spring Training, Benedict was right beside him, watching him and offering advice at the end of the bullpen session. After one session, Benedict yelled out “that was your best one yet”. It was at that point (also after seeing his curve and changeup) that I started thinking Volquez might work out.

Gerrit Cole and Jameson Taillon both were hard throwers who had fastballs that were too easy to hit. Benedict worked with both guys from day one, focusing on making their fastballs harder to hit. Cole has seen success with this approach in the majors so far. Taillon has also done a much better job of throwing at the knees.

Big name pitchers are always going to get the attention. When there’s a reclamation project, a big portion of the success will go to the player, as it should. The same goes for a prospect working out. But the guys who have a hand in all of this are invaluable to a small market team like the Pirates. Benedict has a hand in Charlie Morton’s overhaul, Gerrit Cole and Jeff Locke reaching the majors, the reclamation projects of Francisco Liriano, Edinson Volquez, and others, and possibly the Vance Worley complete turnaround. When he decided to remain in Pittsburgh, that was the best thing to happen to the Pirates this past off-season. And that would have been true, no matter who they signed.

Links and Notes

2014 Draft

**2014 Pittsburgh Pirates Draft Pick Signing Tracker

**Pirates Sign 39th Overall Pick Connor Joe

**Pirates Sign Third Round Pick Jordan Luplow

**Pirates Sign 25th Round Pick, Shortstop Erik Forgione


**Prospect Watch: Josh Bell Stays Hot; Two Draft Picks Off to Good Starts

**Minor League Schedule: Sampson and Morris Look to Continue Strong Seasons

**Josh Bell Named FSL Player of the Week

**Top 10 Pitchers: Do A.J. Morris and Nick Kingham Have a Shot at Pittsburgh This Year?

**Top 10 Hitters: Could Josh Bell Be in Line For a Promotion Soon?

**Prospect Highlights: Alen Hanson Stays Hot, Matt Curry Goes Yard


**Andrew McCutchen Named NL Player of the Week

Tim started Pirates Prospects in 2009 from his home in Virginia, which was 40 minutes from where Pedro Alvarez made his pro debut in Lynchburg. That year, the Lynchburg Hillcats won the Carolina League championship, and Pirates Prospects was born from Tim's reporting along the way. The site has grown over the years to include many more writers, and Tim has gone on to become a credentialed MLB reporter, producing Pirates Prospects each year, and will publish his 11th Prospect Guide this offseason. He has also served as the Pittsburgh Pirates correspondent for Baseball America since 2019. Behind the scenes, Tim is an avid music lover, and most of the money he gets paid to run this site goes to vinyl records.

Support Pirates Prospects

Related articles

join the discussion

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I’m hoping Benedict has a bit of “understanding mom” in him to take care of Cumpton & Locke when both get sent down despite whatever they accomplish up here.

Business is business. If Worley continues to pitch well, Bucs have no choice but to keep him in Pittsburgh.

Btw, who is Benedict’s #2 /likely successor?


Great article, Tim!


i could not agree more, too bad most of the media does not understand the value of a guy like Benedict, IMO, the scouts and development people is where I would put big salaries if I am a small market team, you have to be able to take players off the scrapheap and reinvent them and you have to be able to develop your higher end talent in the minors to be able to take over for guys like McCutchen when he leaves because there is no way the Pirates can pay his next salary and that goes for a few more guys the Pirates have in the majors. In baseball today even the high end salary paying teams lose top talent because then can’t pay them all, the difference between them and the Pirates is the Pirates will be able to replace their top major league talent if they keep guys like Benedict around.


Exactly, leadoff!

Monsoon Harvard

Yeah, I remember that this off season and I never understood why the Pirates haven’t sweetened the pot enough for Benedict to keep him from even wanting to test the waters and interview with another club.

I thought the Pirates would value Benedict more and realize how important it is to keep him with the organization, and would reward him enough to keep him contented. Can’t he be signed to a long term deal?

Lee Young

Well, you know how the Bucs like to keep these kinds of deals quiet? 🙂 🙂

Overall, I agree….I hope he is well compensated.


You can bet that if he turned down that position with the Phillies, the Pirates are paying him VERY well.

Share article

Pirates Prospects Daily

Latest articles

Pirates Prospects Weekly

MONDAY: First Pitch

TUESDAY: Article Drop


THURSDAY: Roundtable

FRIDAY: Discussion

SATURDAY: Pirates Draft Report

SUNDAY: Pirates Business

Latest comments