Pirates Should Be Shopping Paul Maholm

Yesterday, before a lot of the trades started coming through, I took a look at how the market was shaping up, noting that it was looking like a seller’s market.  That opinion didn’t change yesterday, especially with starting pitchers.

Ubaldo Jimenez was traded from the Colorado Rockies to the Cleveland Indians.  Jimenez had a big year last year, but has struggled a bit this year, including a drop in velocity which is always a concern for pitchers.  Regardless, Cleveland sent Drew Pomeranz and Alex White, their first round picks from each of the last two years, along with two other prospects.  Prior to the season, White (47) and Pomeranz (61) both rated in Baseball America’s top 100 prospects.  Pomeranz jumped so high during the season that he finished 14th overall in the mid-season rankings by Baseball America.  Putting this in perspective, value-wise, that’s Jameson Taillon and Luis Heredia, plus two other prospects, in exchange for two years and two months of Jimenez, who has some red flags.

Jimenez is a talented pitcher, so you might expect that type of return for him.  But what about some of the other deals for lesser players?

Seattle traded Doug Fister and David Pauley to Detroit, with Fister being the primary player in the deal.  In exchange they got Francisco Martinez, Casper Wells, and Charlie Furbush.  According to Baseball America’s pre-season rankings, that’s the number 4, 19, and 26 prospects in the Tigers’ system, respectively.

The Diamondbacks added Jason Marquis, who is having a decent year this year, and is under control for two more months, with $2.47 M remaining on his salary.  In exchange for the 32 year old starter, Arizona gave up shortstop prospect Zach Walkers, who rated 29th in the Arizona system prior to the year, and who has a .302/.377/.485 line in 361 at-bats in low-A as a 21 year old.

Then there was a deal that didn’t go through, but not because of the value of the prospects.  Boston had a trade for Rich Harden of the Oakland Athletics, where they were sending Lars Anderson in return.  The deal fell through when there was uncertainty about Harden’s medical history.  That’s the same Rich Harden who missed the entire season up until July, and who has been injury prone throughout his entire career.

Even the relief pitching market got some value, as Koji Uehara was sent to the Texas Rangers in exchange for first baseman Chris Davis and right handed pitcher Tommy Hunter.  That deal allowed Baltimore to trade Derrek Lee to the Pirates.

The Pirates should at least shop Maholm around.

Of the above deals, the only one that doesn’t look appealing would be the Marquis trade, and honestly, that’s the only one that seems to have normal value.  Every other trade has fetched a nice return, considering the players involved.  With this looking like a seller’s market, the Pirates would be foolish if they didn’t at least shop Paul Maholm around today.  There are still teams looking for starting pitching, and with the value being paid on the current market, it would be too short sighted for the Pirates to consider Maholm untouchable.

As we’ve seen the last few days, the Pirates may be contenders for the weak NL Central, but that’s about as far as their chances go.  Adding Derrek Lee is an upgrade from Lyle Overbay, but upgrading one position in the lineup isn’t going to cause the offense to do a complete 180.  The Pirates have been good enough this year to beat up on the weaker teams, and they hold their own with winning teams, but not to the point where they’re on the same level as teams like St. Louis, Philadelphia, or Atlanta.

If the Pirates did deal a guy like Maholm, it might hurt the team in the short run, but probably not as much as it would help in the long run.  The short run impact would be lessened, as the Pirates have Ross Ohlendorf returning at the beginning of August.  In the long run, the Pirates could take advantage of a seller’s market and really provide the team with a serious upgrade.  Worst case scenario, they don’t get the big offer I’m talking about, and they keep Maholm.

I’ve been saying for awhile that the Pirates can be both buyers and sellers at the deadline.  I’ve been saying that they should make moves like the Derrek Lee trade, where the biggest thing they give up is salary relief to the other team.  I still think they could use another bat, specifically an outfielder, but at the same time I also wouldn’t be against dealing Maholm, or for that matter, seeing what guys like Joel Hanrahan, Chris Resop, or Jeff Karstens could fetch on this seller’s market.  The Pirates have some depth in the rotation, and they have some depth in the bullpen to lessen the short term consequences of such a move.  As I said before, it would be too short sighted to pass on a deal that could provide a big boost to the long term of the team, all because you don’t want to lessen the chances in the short term of a team that, honestly, doesn’t look like a contender anywhere outside of the NL Central.

Tim started Pirates Prospects in 2009 from his home in Virginia, which was 40 minutes from where Pedro Alvarez made his pro debut in Lynchburg. That year, the Lynchburg Hillcats won the Carolina League championship, and Pirates Prospects was born from Tim's reporting along the way. The site has grown over the years to include many more writers, and Tim has gone on to become a credentialed MLB reporter, producing Pirates Prospects each year, and will publish his 11th Prospect Guide this offseason. He has also served as the Pittsburgh Pirates correspondent for Baseball America since 2019. Behind the scenes, Tim is an avid music lover, and most of the money he gets paid to run this site goes to vinyl records.

Support Pirates Prospects

Related articles

join the discussion

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jimmy Cali

We are going to trade our best pitcher and tell what to our fans again?     Exactly how many trades has NH “won” in his time here?   

Sorry, its time for NH and his organization to actually start developing pitchers/players he drafts not trade pieces that are already producing at the MLB level for prospects that might turn it around. Is that too much to ask for from this FO?  Start developing players please.

And this depth in the rotation contains 2 guys who can’t pitch more than 6 innings in their starts (and one in Morton is trending downward big time) I don’t think they can afford to give up Maholm who takes the ball every 5th day.  I understand he’s not an ace or even a number 2 starter but the Pirates don’t have anyone else better than him and won’t for the next few years.


Maholm to AZ for Paul Goldschmidt?


This idea is not as far out as I would have thought even a month ago. I really think the GM missed the boat by not starting trading earlier. Waiting till less than 24 hrs before the deadline came really cost. I’d prefer to deal Correia but he wouldn’t bring as much as you’d expect from Maholm. If Maholm were to return as much as comparably mentioned in the article, there’s no doubt about going for it.

The Lee trade was okay. Should never have signed Overbay in the first place. Didn’t lose much with Baker and got enough money probably to replace what was owed Overbay. A slight upgrade at one ML position. WAR says it was a good trade.

The inaction of the past 10 days or so, coupled with a complete collapse of offense at the same time has taken the Pirates pretty much out of the race.


Everyone is acting like the Pirates are out of the race because their offense faltered in a 4 game series at ATL and a 3 game series at PHI (the 2 best pitching staffs in the NL).  Meanwhile, MIL and STL both played home series against CHC and HOU.  At most, this week showed that the Pirates are not on a level playing field with Philly (expected). 

Let’s wait until next Sunday after 4 at home against CHC and 3 at home against SD and then we’ll see if they’re still in the race.  I don’t think the Pirates are a “contender” outside of the NL central but by no means are they completely out of the race.


Second that.  Although it has been a very successful season, we are not to the point of winning a short series with the likes of SF, Philly or Atlanta.  A Pirate fan for life would love to see upgrades for the future and winning seasons and not just for one.   The ridiculous fans that claim we need Ludwig and Willingham and even thought we were there for Pence and Beltran are living in their fantasy leagues and do not understand.  I see no other practical upgrades in the OF and I see nobody being blocked in the minors (AAA or AA) on other teams except for Dayan Vicideo with the WSox.  Upgrade RP or prospects for the future is my vote.  2012 and beyond!!!


Completely agree!! We need to reload our minors with some OFFENSE…. Malholm has been stud this year and should easily get us a great haul of prospects….  Call up Lincoln or Owens and see what they can do…..

Share article

Pirates Prospects Daily

Latest articles

Pirates Prospects Weekly

MONDAY: First Pitch

TUESDAY: Article Drop


THURSDAY: Roundtable

FRIDAY: Discussion

SATURDAY: Pirates Draft Report

SUNDAY: Pirates Business

Latest comments