Where Will Austin Meadows and Reese McGuire Start the Year?

Normally there aren’t many questions about who will make the jump from West Virginia to Bradenton in the Pittsburgh Pirates’ minor league system. The Pirates prefer to have younger players spend an entire season in West Virginia before moving up. Older players in college might go to West Virginia for a few months, and move up in the middle of the season when a roster spot opens. And players who struggled in West Virginia, or who missed part of the season, will often repeat the level, rather than getting a promotion, especially if they are on the young side.

The latter raises two interesting situations for the 2015 Bradenton Marauders and the West Virginia Power. Reese McGuire was strong defensively last year, but the bat struggled in low-A ball. Austin Meadows missed half the season with multiple hamstring injuries, but looked great during the time he was in West Virginia. Looking specifically at the players, you could make a case for either one returning. It might benefit McGuire to return to Low-A and work on his offense. And it might benefit Meadows to get a full season at the same level, just like the Pirates did with Josh Bell in a similar situation a few years ago.

Then there’s the macro look at the two teams involved. The catching position is thin in Bradenton, and loaded in West Virginia. If McGuire goes to West Virginia, he would be the primary catcher, which would prevent 2014 4th round Taylor Gushue from getting regular time. It would also make it nearly impossible for compensation round pick Connor Joe to get any time behind the plate. By moving McGuire up to Bradenton, the Pirates would challenge him at the plate when the numbers are already weak, but would create much more playing time for all of the lower level catchers.

It’s a similar situation for Meadows (and Harold Ramirez, who also missed half the season and could easily be swapped in for Meadows in this scenario). Bradenton doesn’t have many outfield prospects, while West Virginia projects to have a lot of outfielders. The scenario here is a little less extreme, especially if Kevin Krause gets a push to Bradenton (more on that in a bit). But if Meadows does stay down, that means playing time will be cut for Jerrick Suiter, Michael Suchy, and Elvis Escobar. None of those guys are top 50 prospects, but they rank higher than the guys in Bradenton who would benefit from extra playing time if Meadows stays down in West Virginia. The bigger impact would be restricting potential playing time in right field for Connor Joe.

As a note, I’ve talked to both Meadows and McGuire recently, and neither player has received his assignment yet.

The placements of Meadows and McGuire this year will be a big story to watch, and one that could impact a lot of playing time and placement situations in the lower levels. As for the rest of the team, it’s pretty straight forward as usual. For simplicity sake, I put McGuire and Meadows in Bradenton in the following projection, although that isn’t guaranteed. Here are the projected rosters, along with analysis on where there might be position battles.

Position Players

C – Reese McGuire

1B – Edwin Espinal

2B – Erich Weiss

SS – JaCoby Jones

3B – Wyatt Mathisen

LF – Barrett Barnes

CF – Austin Meadows

RF – Kevin Krause

DH – Danny Collins

Bench – Jin-De Jhang, D.J. Crumlich, Chris Diaz, Raul Fortunato

Battling For a Spot – Taylor Lewis, Justin Maffei, Ashley Ponce, Beau Maggi, Maximo Rivera, Jeff Roy, Francisco Diaz, Jordan Steranka, Wes Freeman

Analysis – I outlined the situation with McGuire and Meadows above. I’d expect Espinal, Weiss, Jones, and Mathisen to move up, as all four spent an entire season in West Virginia last year, posting some decent numbers. Out of the four, Jones seems most likely for a mid-season promotion to Altoona, although that will depend on how his defense at shortstop looks, and how his strikeout issues look.

The interesting scenario here is Kevin Krause. He showed some surprising power last year for a ninth round pick. He’s also on the older side, so it wouldn’t hurt to give him an aggressive push. He was drafted as a catcher, although it’s hard seeing him getting playing time behind the plate going forward. If he stays in West Virginia, then he’d be behind Taylor Gushue, and possibly Connor Joe. If McGuire stayed in West Virginia, then Krause would have no shot at playing time. Under the current scenario in Bradenton, he wouldn’t see much playing time behind McGuire, and would be competing with Jin-De Jhang for the backup role. In every scenario, he’d lack the playing time needed to really show improvements at the position.

The Pirates had a similar situation with Wyatt Mathisen last year, and they moved him to third base. Krause has played right field, and it wouldn’t be a bad idea to move him there full-time. This would allow him to focus entirely on the bat, and show whether the power in 2014 was legit, or just a “college guy in the lower levels” thing. Keep in mind that even if he does go to right field full-time, that could very well take place in West Virginia. But with his age, it makes more sense to push him to Bradenton.

As for the DH spot and the bench, outside of Jhang, there aren’t many locks for the team. You could pick any 3-4 players from that list to fill the final bench spots and the DH role.


SP – Luis Heredia

SP – Clay Holmes

SP – Cody Dickson

SP – Tyler Eppler

SP – Felipe Gonzalez

Analysis – I think Heredia, Holmes, and Dickson are locks for the team. Heredia has spent parts of two seasons in West Virginia, and it only makes sense to move him up. Holmes was ticketed for Bradenton last year before his injury. Dickson spent a full season in West Virginia, and it’s only natural for him to move up to the next level.

I’ve got Eppler getting an aggressive push due to his strong performance in short-season ball last year. The Pirates have taken the same path in recent years with guys like Adrian Sampson and Chad Kuhl.

With the final spot, I listed Felipe Gonzalez. This is basically an organizational spot, although it could be filled by one of the bullpen guys like Justin Topa, or even someone who didn’t make the cut in Altoona. One of the college guys in West Virginia could move up (I’ll profile them tomorrow). I also wouldn’t be surprised if Jameson Taillon makes a few starts in Bradenton early in the season as part of his rehab process. Finally, there’s the possibility that the PTBNL in the Travis Snider trade could be an option for the final spot in the rotation. Right now I’ve got it projected as filler, and this will be something to watch as the Bradenton roster takes shape.

RP – Ryan Hafner

RP – Henry Hirsch

RP – Isaac Sanchez

RP – Brett McKinney

RP – Jhondaniel Medina

RP – Justin Topa

RP – Jared LaKind

Battling For a Spot – Andy Otamendi, Clario Perez, Oderman Rocha, Miguel Rosario, Rinku Singh, Josh Smith, Jerry Mulderig, Zack Von Rosenberg

Analysis – Just like the bench, these spots are entirely up in the air. I feel a little bit better about projecting these spots than I do the bench spots. That’s mostly because the guys projected above are mostly hard throwers, while the guys listed as battling for a spot are either soft tossers, hard throwers with bigger control issues, or hard throwers who don’t have a fastball as good as the guys on the list.

Tim started Pirates Prospects in 2009 from his home in Virginia, which was 40 minutes from where Pedro Alvarez made his pro debut in Lynchburg. That year, the Lynchburg Hillcats won the Carolina League championship, and Pirates Prospects was born from Tim's reporting along the way. The site has grown over the years to include many more writers, and Tim has gone on to become a credentialed MLB reporter, producing Pirates Prospects each year, and will publish his 11th Prospect Guide this offseason. He has also served as the Pittsburgh Pirates correspondent for Baseball America since 2019. Behind the scenes, Tim is an avid music lover, and most of the money he gets paid to run this site goes to vinyl records.

Support Pirates Prospects

Related articles

join the discussion

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

meadows is a special player feel free to fast track him, and if polanco and his long looping swing stumbles this yr. meadows could step right in. super star players sometimes make mlb before thier 21st birthday.


Long,short,looping or drooping as long as bat mets ball in the right spot getting there is mote. That is the question with polanco, I tend to think he will hit very well this year, we shall see won’t we.


Long at times, but ” looping ” ????? Try again.


IMO, McGuire did not hit that bad at WV,
.262.307.334.642 True, he did not tear it up, but he is a contact hitter and I would not think that moving from WV to Bradenton would be that big of a problem offensively, he did had 9 passed balls last year, might be he needs to work on his defense, something he can do at Bradenton. Catcher defense is far more important than their offense. If McGuire can get through the minors hitting somewhere around .250 he will be a valuable asset.


Meadows moving up is a no-brainer for me. Far, far more advanced than Josh Bell at the same stage.

As for McGuire, there isn’t a single more important prospect in the system. You do what is best for him and shuffle the other peices to fit.

Also see Stephen Tarpley moving into that last spot in the rotation by mid-season as a college guy who scouts say was a fast riser in the second half of last year.


Meadows dominated in a few ABs at SS-A in 2013 and adjusted so easy last year. He doesn’t turn 20 until May. He could be a rare ultra fast track guy like a Trout or Harper if he goes to Bradenton and dominates. His hands and everything else are so calm. He should have one of the most picturesque swings in the game.


I think they’ll have to watch the K’s against advanced spin as he moves up, but I very much agree.

The body is there, the skills are there, the swing is there. And he’s gonna end up a left fielder, regardless, so there’s really no need to hold him back for defensive purposes.

This is the exact kind of prospect you push to failure, and then back off and let him adjust. AA at-bats this year should happen.


He gets compared to Jay Bruce a lot but Meadows has shown better patience and discipline already than Bruce ever did in the minors. Bruce is turning into Adam Dunn that walks less but plays defense…Meadows could be a .300+ hitter that hits 20+ HR. Bruce has had a .350 obp once and Meadows hopefully will do that close to every year.


I think it is getting more and more difficult to keep past prospects in perspective with the incredible amount of additional related work we have today, but Jay Bruce was an absolute stud of a prospect. #1 in all of baseball at one point, if I remember correctly.

May seem like a bit of a slight to Meadows, especially after last season, but using Jay Bruce as a comp for him is *extremely* high praise.


I remember going to Dayton from Columbus to watch my cousin pitch for Toronto’s affiliate and Bruce played and you immediately thought “Why is he here?” He was fully developed and man among boys at 19. We waited 15 innings for my cousin to get in and he took the loss in the bottom of the 15th. Tough game.


Great story, buddy. Thanks for sharing!

How far did your cousin get, if you don’t mind me asking?


NP. NMR. Well, he was a twin. Josh Sowers and he was a righty. One year and out. His brother Jeremy, the lefty, pitched for the Indians parts of 4 years, had shoulder surgery, and then was done at about 28. He had potential but it just didn’t work out. They both got degrees though which isn’t common for ballplayers. Jeremy just took a job with the Orioles doing video and stuff like that. He should go far with the baseball background and the masters degree. With me being a huge baseball fan it was exciting to live vicariously through those two.


I will definitely be getting to Bradenton to see the Marauders this year. So much exciting talent and prospects to see there.


Me to.

Lee Foo Young

I had plans for ST this year, but the mother-in-law’s health problems put a kabosh on those plans.

It wouldn’t be as much fun without my wife.


Family first,best wishes and prayers to you and yours.


There is no crying in baseball Lee !


Sorry to hear that. My wife goes but she is more into people watching than the game usually.


Agreed. Tim said yesterday this is the best squad in the org and now I see why.

Could be a little light on arms, but Holmes and Dickson both have breakout potential.


Is Jhang definitely starting at Altoona? I thought he would repeat A+ for sure.


Looks like Tim has him repeating, which seems to make sense.

Lee Foo Young

Any pitcher with a first name of “Tyler” gets ME fired up :).

Share article

Pirates Prospects Daily

Latest articles

Pirates Prospects Weekly

MONDAY: First Pitch

TUESDAY: Article Drop


THURSDAY: Roundtable

FRIDAY: Discussion

SATURDAY: Pirates Draft Report

SUNDAY: Pirates Business

Latest comments