32 F
Friday, December 9, 2022

Neal Huntington on Who Could Join the Pirates When Rosters Expand Tomorrow

Major League Baseball rosters expand tomorrow, with teams able to call up anyone on the 40-man roster, giving them the possibility for an active roster that can hold up to 40 players. Not all of the guys on the 40-man roster will be called up, but you can expect the Pirates to make several moves.

“We’re going to be very cognizant of the numbers that we add to this club,” Pittsburgh Pirates’ General Manager Neal Huntington said. “We’ve got some guys that are obvious additions, like [Gerrit] Cole and [Jeff] Locke, and [Gregory] Polanco is coming back, and we get Stolmy Pimentel off the disabled list. So you’re already at 29 before you start to talk about guys that have spent the majority or their recent time at Triple A.”

Cole, Locke, and Polanco were optioned in the last week, allowing the Pirates to add additional bench players before rosters expanded. All of them will be eligible for the post-season roster this year, despite being in the minors on August 31st, due to a rule change that made everyone on the 40-man roster eligible for the post-season. Previously the rule was that you had to be on the 25-man roster on August 31st to be eligible.

In Polanco’s case, he was sent down to get some regular work in Triple-A, while Travis Snider got starts in right field. Snider went down with an injury a few days later, but Andrew Lambo took over as the starter recently. Huntington said that he feels Polanco has been doing well in his time in Indianapolis.

“We think so,” Huntington said, when asked if the time for Polanco has been beneficial. “Just to get the at bats, just to get out and hit again. After the four-day layoff where Travis [Snider] was swinging the bat so well and deserved to continue to play, Gregory looked a little rough. So that was where we took the opportunity to give him a reach for at bats in Triple A.”

You can expect Polanco, Cole, Locke, and Pimentel to be added. But who else will join the team? I posted my predictions earlier this week, noting that a lot of bullpen arms could come up, along with several bench players. Huntington didn’t want to comment on the moves before they happened. He did discuss what went into the decision to call a specific player up.

“Our first three, four, and five years here, September call ups have been about opportunity and rewards and guys who were getting a chance to see if they belong on next years club,” Huntington said. “This year’s September call ups, and last year’s September call ups are about giving a player’s skill set that Clint can use to win a game. So there may be some guys that you all look at and say ‘I wonder why he didn’t he get call up and why did he get called up.’ Again, the recognition is these are guys that help Clint manage to win a game in some way, shape, or form.”

One area where the Pirates obviously have a need has been the bullpen. They’ve been looking for bullpen help over the last month, and it can only be expected that they’ll add players from the minors tomorrow. Casey Sadler will probably be one of those guys. You could also assume that Ernesto Frieri will come up, since the Pirates are paying him the remainder of his $3.8 M salary. John Holdzkom is a sleeper who was added by the Pirates as a minor league free agent this year, and who has been throwing in the upper 90s with Indianapolis. But I don’t think anyone would be a guarantee, based on Huntington’s comments.

“There will be some surprises that will make some people scratch their head,” Huntington said.

There’s no one who would be a total shock to be left in the minors, and that includes Frieri, who has continued his struggles with Indianapolis, and who would require a 40-man roster spot. There are a few guys who could be called up for specific skills, despite not having the best numbers. Chase d’Arnaud is an example here. He only has a .662 OPS, but he has a lot of speed, is an excellent base stealer, can play a lot of different positions, and has done well against lefties in his career. I’ve heard some talk that d’Arnaud is in the discussions to come up, although I don’t know if that would qualify as a surprise. It will be interesting to see these surprises when rosters expand tomorrow.

+ posts

Tim started Pirates Prospects in 2009 from his home in Virginia, which was 40 minutes from where Pedro Alvarez made his pro debut in Lynchburg. That year, the Lynchburg Hillcats won the Carolina League championship, and Pirates Prospects was born from Tim's reporting along the way. The site has grown over the years to include many more writers, and Tim has gone on to become a credentialed MLB reporter, producing Pirates Prospects each year, and will publish his 11th Prospect Guide this offseason. He has also served as the Pittsburgh Pirates correspondent for Baseball America since 2019. Behind the scenes, Tim is an avid music lover, and most of the money he gets paid to run this site goes to vinyl records.


Pirates Prospects has been independently owned and operated since 2009, entirely due to the support of our readers. The site is now completely free, funded entirely by user support. By supporting the site, you are supporting independent writers, one of the best Pittsburgh Pirates communities online, and our mission for the most complete Pirates coverage available.

Related articles

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

IMO, Sadler is of no use to this team right now. He is not a relief pitcher and they are not going to let him start. Has anyone heard from Cumpton in the last decade and he is a pretty good pitcher, could have been of good use yesterday instead of Hughes having to go 2 innings. I know, Clint will say they are saving him for long relief! WoW.

Lukas Sutton

Come on, Hughes was at 10 pitches after the inning. If he pulls him and puts in anyone not named Watson or Melancon fans would say “why couldnt Hughes go another few hitters at least?”. Hughes is the 3rd best guy the Pirates have out of the pen right now and absolutely was a normal call for a manager to leave in. Cumpton has given up at least 1 run in all of his relief outings this year, so no reason to think he was a better call there. Clint rolled with his best guy available, tip the hat to the Reds.

Spa City



“Neal Huntington on ‘Whom’ Could Join the Pirates When Rosters Expand Tomorrow?”

Really? That doesn’t seem right at all.

Spa City

Presumably you would follow “on” with an objective case pronoun, right? But to each her own.

Mostly I was just aiming for wraparound humour based on my silly joke from last week.

I am not working today due to the federal holiday, so I had some extra time to kill on the Pirate Prospects web-site.

dr dng

I’d like to see d’Arnaud come up to PR when Davis draws a walks late in the game and we are down one run.

Here is my surprise call up prediction….
“The Pirates have 4 catchers on the roster by September 3.”

Dom DiDominic

Really hoping the last ab for moral was today. I know cueto is good, but that was awful, wasted out in a big game.


3D: Living in Tennessee, we must be in the home-viewing area of Cincy because I cannot watch the game on the Pirate Feed, and have to listen to the Cincy folks. I thought the pitch to Morel was inside, and so did he; the guy they really criticized was Ike Davis. Early in the AB they talked about his habit of bouncing the bat down and back up before swinging and that he would not be able to handle a pitch high in the strike zone on the inside corner. He swung and missed at one that was inside, and then hit that weak blooper on the next one thrown in exactly the same place. That bounce is classic little league stuff – very rare to see something that bad from a guy in the majors, but it makes me wonder if he just does not want to change?


Can’t wait to see the highlight of A.J. Morris hitting a homer.

Leefoo Rug Bug

Definitely rooting for Chase.

Just say ‘no’ to Ernesto.


I see Chase D’arnaud as a definite addition for pinch running purposes.

Erik Johnson

He can also play 6 positions, so he gives them some flexibility

Share article

Latest articles


Latest comments