58.5 F
Wednesday, December 7, 2022

Neal Huntington on the Upcoming Amateur Draft

Pittsburgh Pirates GM Neal Huntington spoke with the media recently about the Pittsburgh Pirates approach with this upcoming draft. The Pirates are in an unfamiliar position, making their first pick with the 24th overall selection.

The team’s focus remains the same, but the amount of work going into that first pick definitely increases. There is more uncertainty the further you get from the top and it makes it tougher to get a solid prospect with that pick.

In the past, you could expect a higher priced player to drop due to bonus demands, so you had a chance to get someone with huge upside and a price tag to match, later in the first round. Now with the draft bonus pool cap in place, once a player drops past a certain point, there is no sense in wasting a first round pick on him.

We saw what could happen just two years ago when the Pirates gambled on Mark Appel and he stuck to his bonus demands. It ended up working out okay with the extra pick in 2013, but when you’re picking 24th in a strong draft class, there is no guarantee that you will get anywhere close to the same talent the following season with the compensation pick.

What that all means is that it is important to make the right selection this year for where they are picking and hopefully it’s a “problem” that the Pirates have every year in the future. Huntington broke down his thinking on the draft and the Pirates plans of attack to make sure they do make that right selection.

“It’s a lot easier when you’re pick one, two or four to have a pretty good feel for who is going to get to you, so it’s a bit more of a challenge this year picking 24, which we’ll gladly take and hopefully figure out a way to start picking 28th, 29th and 30 at some point here in the near future.”

Huntington praised the work that the scouts have already done up to this point and acknowledged the amount of work they still have to do as the draft gets closer.

“Our guys are after it, they do such a great job. They’re doing the best you can to narrow down to make sure you get deep looks at the guys you think are going to be in the mix not only at 24 but the competitive balance pick and second-round pick. Again, I just can’t say enough good things about the scouting department.”

The type of player the Pirates will likely get, won’t match the talent/reputation of the top names that Huntington has picked himself since taking over the draft in 2008. That doesn’t mean you ignore those players, but the majority of the time spent scouting them is better spent elsewhere.

“It’s a little bit mixed in that teams picking 24th aren’t taking Pedro Alvarez and they weren’t taking Gerrit Cole. You do your due diligence in case a guy falls for some unexpected reason, but you’re not wearing out a guy that’s going to go in the Top 5. So it’s a different number of looks, maybe a larger number of guys you’re trying to get good looks at, but you don’t have to wear out the guys who are going to go 1, 2, 3, 4. You do your homework and make sure you’re comfortable that if they get to you, you’re happy and you know why you’re happy and you know maybe why they got to you.”

That means that the Pirates aren’t concentrating on the players that have been at the top all season, such as Tyler Kolek, a big prep righty that has no problem throwing high 90’s and dominating lesser competition. Kolek won’t last longer than the first five picks and could very well go first overall. He has been in that general area all year. Same for Alex Jackson, a catcher out of high school in California. He has been a top five pick all year and only cemented his place with a strong performance in his senior year.

Players like prep outfielder Braxton Davidson, prep righty Scott Blewett and college lefty Sean Newcomb have been in the Pirates range all year. They are examples of players that are meeting, but not exceeding expectations. Assuming the Pirates feel the same way about those players as the general consensus does, they are being heavily scouted at every opportunity. Last year, we heard that Huntington himself went to scout Reese McGuire multiple times, so there was a good idea that the Pirates honed in on him and really liked him.

The scouts are concentrating more on a group that has been mentioned later in the draft, players that may start out as second round type picks, so if they do well, you consider them first round and if they hold ground, you have those 65th and 74th overall picks that are almost as important as that first round pick.

“It doesn’t mean we’ve gotta see more guys, we’ve got a great number of scouts out there and our area guys get after it. We’ve got a large number of national and regional supervisors that get after it, so we’ll have deep looks at, typically we get almost double-digits with guys we’ve got the supervisor looks at and not just our area guys which is a good thing for us as an organization. Different set of guys, you shift your focus a little bit.”

What he doesn’t mention, but should be pointed out, is that those players that look like they are obvious top 5-10 picks, have been seen by their scouts in the past. So while they haven’t seen a lot of them this year, they already have a good sense of what they are looking at. If there is buzz that a certain player is dropping, they will get some extra eyes on them for late looks.

An example of a player that was dropping is shortstop Trea Turner from North Carolina State. He was ranked top five early this year, then he started hitting a lot of singles and wasn’t hitting for average. Then some scouts questioned his defensive ability. There is a huge difference between a future shortstop and future second baseman, or a third baseman not hitting for power. Turner has turned things around recently, so his fall has probably halted. The Pirates scouted Turner in high school and even drafted him in the 20th round in 2011. Since then, his NC State team has been scouted for three years, so they have a great idea of what he is as a player.

That also means that they got a look at Turner’s teammate Carlos Rodon, who was picked by many as the first overall pick this year. He has dropped a little, but not much. A late injury or real bad stretch could happen, you don’t want to get a player that way, but they already know about Rodon and it won’t matter much that they didn’t see every single start. If they feel he, or a similar player could drop to them, then there is information out there and still time to get a better look.

As the draft gets closer, we will get a better idea of who the Pirates might take. For now, as Huntington mentioned, it’s obviously a big group that has to be narrowed down into their own rankings, so as players go off the board, they can cross them off their list and go with the best player available. The key is to get their best player available and from the sounds of things, the Pirates are putting in the work to make sure that is what they get.

+ posts

John started working at Pirates Prospects in 2009, but his connection to the Pittsburgh Pirates started exactly 100 years earlier when Dots Miller debuted for the 1909 World Series champions. John was born in Kearny, NJ, two blocks from the house where Dots Miller grew up. From that hometown hero connection came a love of Pirates history, as well as the sport of baseball.

When he didn't make it as a lefty pitcher with an 80+ MPH fastball and a slider that needed work, John turned to covering the game, eventually focusing in on the prospects side, where his interest was pushed by the big league team being below .500 for so long. John has covered the minors in some form since the 2002 season, and leads the draft and international coverage on Pirates Prospects. He writes daily on Pittsburgh Baseball History, when he's not covering the entire system daily throughout the entire year on Pirates Prospects.


Pirates Prospects has been independently owned and operated since 2009, entirely due to the support of our readers. The site is now completely free, funded entirely by user support. By supporting the site, you are supporting independent writers, one of the best Pittsburgh Pirates communities online, and our mission for the most complete Pirates coverage available.

Related articles

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I think Huntington will have more to pick from next year…..pick will be a lot higher based on the major league team performance in 2014…..unless of course they can turn it around!


Or Huntington’s replacement

4th in the division

Picking in top 10

All to buy another year of “control” over the next Dave Parker

Attendance down 15% so of course there will be LESS money to spend

Winning is hard and requires a strong commitment – to winning


Thats the first thing I agree with that you’ve said in awhile. It does. And it requires a committment to winning NOW, not having a competitive team each year, while never making the necessary moves to get the flag flying overhead. There has to be a balance, hopefully we find it


Huntington won’t be replaced, 4th in the division on April 24, I would have rather have an extra year of control of Polanco in his prime than two months of Polanco in his age 22 season, attendance is down mainly due to school still being in session and the hockey playoffs sucking fans away (As it should, playoffs > regular season), Pirates have shown nothing that suggests they AREN’T committed to winning.

Now, let us move on instead of trying to write a narrative.


Year of control date was April 20th…..


What flavor of koolaid is Neil serving?


The flavor of Kool-Aid called “Common Sense – No Narrative Added”. It is quite healthy for the brain and helps with level-headed thinking.

Sheesh, what is it with some people? Three weeks in “OMG THE SEASON IS OVER! WE WILL NEVER WIN AGAIN!”, Polanco is more valuable and easier to afford if kept down past the cut off date. To answer Macchamp74 as well, the Super 2 cut off date hasn’t passed. Polanco would be given an extra year of control but still cost a lot more to sign long term if given a 4th year of arbitration which he would acquire if brought up now.

If you haven’t ever watched a game in April, attendance is ALWAYS LOW. Rarely have sellouts occurred in April because of school. It also doesn’t help when you have a Saturday game coinciding with a Pens home playoff game.

Lastly, for the love of God am I sick of seeing people say “They aren’t committed to winnings rabble rabble rabble.” Now let us take a look at what it takes to make a small market winner and see if the Pirates have done it the past several years.

– Strong commitment to drafting and development? Check.
– Strong commitment to international signing? Check.
– Smart FA signings that do not break the bank? Check.
– Long term thinking over short term thinking? Check.
– July/Acquisitions to benefit the team? Check.
– Extension of young, homegrown talent? Check.

– FO that does not act in haste? Check

But, you know what, forget all that stuff. I guess they aren’t committed to winning.


He may be able to choose higher if that is what you mean. This year’s class is one of the most loaded in recent memory. Guys like Justus Sheffield, in any other draft, is a top 15 pick. This draft, he may be lucky to go in the first round.


Jeff Hoffman anyone? Could be this years sean Manea

S Brooks

I really think the bonus cap is the most regressive feature of the CBA and needs to be abolished.


Agreed- its ridiculous, the CBA is garbage as it pertains to this issue. I again vote to get rid of the “best player” mentality and replace it with, “projected most valuable player to the organization” in terms of draft. A right handed pitcher should be handicapped vs. an equal talent projected shortstop, third baseman, or lefty starter by 2-4 position spots in the draft.

Share article

Latest articles


Latest comments